The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Tipping point: Afoa banned for Heineken Cup semi

Ulster tight-head John Afoa has been handed a four week ban for his dangerous tackle on Felix Jones.

Image: ©INPHO/Cathal Noonan

JOHN AFOA WILL miss Ulster’s Heineken Cup semi-final against Edinburgh after being handed a four-week suspension by the ERC today.

The Kiwi prop was cited for a dangerous ‘tip tackle’ on Felix Jones during the northern province’s 22-16 win over Munster by commissioner Peter Larter.

Afoa plead not guilty at today’s hearing in Dublin, but judicial officer Jean-Nöel Couraud upheld the complaint.

Couraud ruled that the offence had warranted a red card and placed a provisional ban of six weeks on the former All Black, with an extra week to act as a deterrent to others.

That suspension would have ruled the tight-head out of the rest of the season, including a potential Heineken Cup final.

A statement from the ERC says that Couraud subsequently “considered the mitigating factors, including the player’s clean record, good character, age and experience,” before reducing the ban by three weeks.

Head coach, Brian McLaughlin, and director of rugby, David Humphreys will not be able to call on Afoa until after 7 May, meaning his season will be over if Ulster do not make it into the Pro12 play-offs or the Heineken Cup final in Twickenham.

Here’s the tackle again.



YouTube credit: TheUAFC

“Ulster Rugby is disappointed with the outcome,” said a statement from the province, which added: “John Afoa himself is very disappointed, particularly in view of his outstanding disciplinary record where he has never previously received a yellow or red card during his professional career.”

Club first: Farrell turns down England role

Shuffling the pack: Leinster make 12 changes for Edinburgh visit

Read next:

Comments (7 Comments)

  • Poite is the one id ban, perfect view, English refs Pearson and Barnes were withdrawn from the summer test for incorrect decisions they made in the six nations, same thing should happen him

    Reply
  • Think 3 weeks is about right. I don’t think there was any malice in it but going to happen when a player weighing about 85kg runs into a guy about 40kg heavier.
    Hopefully he’s not missed for the semi.

    Reply
  • Not a terrible tackle but if Jones hadnt twisted to land on his back it could have been worse. If he had landed in the point of his shoulder he could have been seriously hurt.

    I hate to see Poite as the ref for any game.

    Come on Munster for the rest of the season and best of luck to Ulster for the Heino Cup.

    Reply
  • Rob 13/04/12 #

    this thing is going around in circles – see it used be that players were paranoid about this type of tackle – so they’d try to pull out of it or let go of the other player – now we’ve decided that dropping a player is supremely dangerous – so it seems to me that this was the only real option Afoa had to complete the tackle.
    people need to hit youtube to remind themselves what a spear tackle really is! this was a tough but fair tackle which injured no one – and never looked like injuring anyone! ban is ridiculous!
    ps Leinster supporter so i’m reasonably objective here.

    Reply
  • Bar he had laid him down with a pillow beneath his head and tucked him on under a duvet he was getting banned going too far the other direction with strictness in tackling.

    Reply

Add New Comment