The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

This study says NFL teams would be crazy not to draft players with criminal records

A professor has crunched the numbers…

Bad boy: New York Jets wide receiver Plaxico Burress.
Bad boy: New York Jets wide receiver Plaxico Burress.
Image: Lynne Sladky/AP/Press Association Images

AN ECONOMICS PROFESSOR from Hamilton College says NFL teams should stockpile criminals in the draft, the AP reports.

Fine, he doesn’t say that exactly.

But he found that players who have been arrested in college performed (based on career starts) just as well in the NFL, and are selected 15 picks later in the draft on average.

Stephen Wu, the professor who ran the study, separated all draftees from 2005 to 2009 into four groups:

  1. Players with no suspensions or legal problems in college
  2. Players suspended one game or more for violating team or university rules
  3. Players arrested and charged with a crime
  4. Players arrested, but not charged

He found that the only group that performed worse on the field, was Group 2. Group 3 — players who were arrested but not charged — faired just as well as Group 1, despite being taken later in the draft on average. And Group 4 — players who were arrested by never charged — actually has a better track record than Group 1.

Therefore, teams that pass on prospects based on their criminal records are doing it wrong.

Intuitively, this makes sense.

Good coaches, including Bill Belichick, draft based on value and don’t fall in love with any single player. So if a player’s stock drops because of a frivolous off-field incident, their value goes up.

Read more at Business Insider

VIDEO: Nets fan gets hit by ball while texting

Published with permission from:

Business Insider
Business Insider is a business site with strong financial, media and tech focus.

Read next:

Comments (4 Comments)

  • Odd using Belichick as an example of someone who might draft such players – the core of his Pats roster over the years has been “character” guys, along with a couple of others like Dillon and Moss who BB reckoned would be kept in check by the rest. Not for him the approach of the Bad News Bengals whose number of convictions was seemingly greater than their wins.

    No disrespect to Professor Wu’s study but that final par is throwing a few things together that don’t necessarily belong.

    Reply
  • Article is completely missing the point. Players who are in trouble off the field are very harshly dealt with at the professional level. Roger Goodell doesn’t give many chances to players for off-the-field incidents so suspensions, which are critical in such short seasons, would be massive blows to a team’s chances of making the playoffs.

    Reply
  • But how do they perform off the field? Are they just as likely to get arrested or have legal problems after college as during it? Many teams could be passing on the risk of a multimillion dollar talent ending up in prison again, could have very little to do with on field performance.

    Reply

Add New Comment