The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 10 °C Thursday 23 May, 2013

Reaction: Coach, captain lament ‘missed opportunity’ as Scotland make Ireland suffer

After another tepid second half display from Ireland, there is only pride to be salvaged.

Image: ©INPHO/Dan Sheridan

IN THE END, even the ordinarily constantly-upbeat Jamie Heaslip had to change his tune.

Asked where the confidence of Cardiff had evaporated to after a horrific 12 – 8 defeat to what, for 40 minutes, looked a beaten Scotland side; Heaslip replied with his media training still on auto-pilot.

“I think we’re in a good place…”

It was too late. The words were already out, a nation already disenfranchised from a team whose players offer so much in the club game, yet deliver so intermittently when dressed in green.

“… but we’re in a mixed place,” the captain added immediately to RTE Sport.

“We’re putting ourselves into position, creating opportunities. In Wales we converted them, last week we didn’t and unfortunately this time we converted some of them, but not all.”

Opportunities passed was the theme of Declan Kidney’s immediate analysis post-match, as the coach tried to make sense of the wreckage of a year that began with so much promise.

“It’s so difficult at the moment, because we know we went a lot of the way there, but we didn’t manage to finish them off.”

Ireland managed to control every facet of the game in the first half, yet only led 3-0 at the break after debutant number 10 Paddy Jackson missed one shot at goal and was elected to kick two more to the corner.

Two roles

With the ball-in-hand, Jackson’s contribution was sound. His passing setting fellow first-cap Luke Marshall on lines to expose the Scottish midfield.

“There are two roles for an out-half,” Kidney said after picking a squad which allowed only one kicking option to take the field at any one time.

“There’s the playing of the game and there’s place-kicking. Unfortunately there was a few place-kicks that went awry, but it was more the other opportunities that cost us at the end of the day.”

Indeed, the coach and captain will look back to the early openings which were stunted by Scottish back-rows getting vital hands in to slow ball down. And a decision of Keith Earls to elect for a route outside Sean Maitland when Brian O’Driscoll was steaming into central space.

With his contract expiring in the summer, all likelihood of the former Munster man winning an extension from the union is now lost.

“My role is all about getting ready for the next match.” Kidney says of the challenge of inviting France to Dublin for a fixture nobody imagined could be billed as this season’s ‘wooden spoon’ fixture.

“We have to regroup now and take that adversity on the chin and  learn how to win these tight matches.

“Six points against England, four points here. We’ve been knocking on the door in these matches, but we have to learn how to finish them out. Sometimes that’s absorbing pressure and putting more pressure on the opposition than we have been doing.”

Heaslip, who was one of Ireland’s stand-out players in the first half but ended it taking flak for some tentative decision-making as a captain pointed to two remaining fixtures that presented nothing tangible for Ireland to play for.

“Now it’s all about lads playing for a bit of pride – definitely, there’s gonna be  some sore bodies in there. It’s a tough pill to take. It’s a down changing room, but we have a couple of days to get over it.

The players will eventually get over it. The public, not so much. Certainly, there can’t have been many that thought of the phrase ‘a good place’ after watching events in Edinburgh.

A good place to die hard, perhaps.

How Twitter reacted to Scotland v Ireland

Open Thread: Is it time for Declan Kidney to resign?

Read next:

Comments (13 Comments)

  • Why is Heaslip captain??
    His best days are behind him.. Jordi Murphy is much better then him with Leinster & I think he deserves an Irish call.
    Kearney or O’Mahony should be named captain, Heaslip just isn’t cut out for it.
    And Keith Earls needs to drive back to Limerick and stay there. McFadden should be on the team, much better then Earls.
    Fitzgerald should of replaced Earls not Gilroy.

    Reply
    • You need to watch some rugby and stay watching it until you have a clue what your talking about. Earls is a better winger than McFadden, Jordi Murphy for Ireland, are you serious?

      Reply
    • Oh I do watch rugby.
      Earls was shit today. Shit.
      Maybe it’s personal preference but I think McFadden is much better.
      And as for Jordi Murphy, YES, I’m totally serious. Maybe you missed last nights Leinster match, or any other match Murphy has played in. The guy is awesome.

      Reply
    • When Jordi murphy gets a game ahead of heaslip for Leinster then maybe he’ll get a game for Ireland. Anyway he’s not an 8

      Reply
    • Murphy was good against a very poor team, is this your Carlsberg moment, he has a great future , it’s the present 8 you need to look at or not, one can only live on ones past for so long, we are so short of our good players whom are injured.

      Reply
  • mullah 24/02/13 #

    Absolute disgrace no excuse. Total dis service to brian O’Driscoll. Why o why did we not start with Madigan at ten? With McFadden on wing also we would have won that match easily – I am a Munster supporter. It is sickening. Hopefully Conor o’shea has a feeling if patriotism and will take on job!

    Reply
    • Maybe because Madigan has been playing 15 all season? Perhaps we should throw caution to the wind now and start Cave and Marshall together with Madigan at fb and kicking? Bring Tol into the back row, drop heaslip….

      Reply
    • TOD..Lol… Don’t put TOL anywhere near the back row…

      Reply
    • Maybe the reason he is playing fullback is due to the fact the current Irish ten is the Leinster 10 is also the current Ireland 10. Is it not better that he is gaining experience rather than sitting on the bench?

      Reply
    • Of course Stafford, but people can’t really expect him to start at 10 for Ireland so. Maybe DK should have dropped Kearney to allow for Mads?

      Reply
    • Madigan isn’t as good as Kearney. This is one aspect where it is difficult for kidney. O’ Gara is out of form, paddy Jackson is starting at ten but doesn’t goal kick or isn’t the main playmaker, and neither madigan or Keatley is starting regularly. It’s a difficult choice, go with o Gara to kick goals and hope his flaws aren’t exposed or go with Jackson and hope his goal kicking stands up. Which brings about the main point that the younger players should have been tried earlier.

      Reply
  • When will ye Leinster fans realise that playing a few good games in the Rabo does not make you international standard. Earls should have put O Driscoll in no doubt but replacing him with McFadden isn’t the answer. Every week ye have a new Munster player to blame. The team as a whole is not performing.

    Reply
  • Declan kidney took a chance today with Jackson, did it work? Short term no. Long term yes.
    There is no point giving out about the fly half selection because who would have replaced him, O Gara? From his 20 mins of playing certainly not, Madigan ? Possibly, but still, If Madigan started,the post match reviews would still have carried the same general consensus of inexperience.

    Reply

Add New Comment