The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Top, top analysis: Power Ranking the Six Nations pundits

George Hook, Keith Wood and Shane Horgan all feature, while Jeremy Guscott’s Gladiators days are recalled.

7. Jonathan Davies

The BBC’s chief Welsh rugby expert is normally quite calm and measured in his analysis. Except, of course, when it comes to Italy’s Mirco Bergamasco, who he considers “absolutely ridiculous” and a “clown”.



YouTube credit: LasGarzas11

6. Jeremy Guscott

Unlike some pundits, Guscott stands out for his willingness to offer honest and insightful criticisms of players. Still though, it’s a far cry from his Gladiators days, when he provoked the ire of Wolf and prompted snarky remarks from commentators (“that’s the fastest Jeremy’s moved all season”).



YouTube credit: boomchikaz

5. Keith Wood

Great players often don’t make great pundits, and vice-versa, but Keith Wood is one of the few exceptions to the rule.



YouTube credit: Conor Ryan

4. Shane Horgan

Horgan has provided some much-needed freshness to the RTE panel. His technical knowledge and deep familiarity with modern rugby render him an asset to the station, and help him stand out from the three wise men.



YouTube credit: rte

3. Brent Pope

Rendered silent by the overly loquacious George Hook if Apres Match were to be believed, in truth, Brent Pope provides a welcome balance to the incendiary thoughts of his more provocative colleague. The two consequently serve as an effective yin-and-yang-style double-act, as a result of this contrast.



YouTube credit: georgehooktv

2. Conor O’Shea

Not only is he one of the sport’s most intelligent voices, but crucially, unlike the majority of his colleagues, he also happens to be operating in a coaching capacity at the top of the sport, and has enjoyed considerable success in his still relatively brief time as Director of Rugby at Harlequins.



YouTube credit: RugbyMedia

1. George Hook

At this stage, Hook has slagged off pretty much every noteworthy rugby player in the world. However, who says you always have to be right to make a good pundit? Hook’s analysis is consistently passionate, honest and entertaining, and that’s all rugby fans can ask for essentially. Moreover, despite effectively being rugby’s answer to Eamon Dunphy, he doesn’t really seem to like his fellow RTE sports analyst.



YouTube credit: rte

Sweetnam included in new-look Ireland squad named for U20 6 Nations games>

England hit by injuries ahead of 6 Nations opener>

Read next:

Comments (10 Comments)

  • downside of the six nations is john inverdale and his jingoistic one eyed view.

    Reply
  • Ah come on. Hook is a caricature who has admitted he watches little ruby before. He should not be taken seriously.
    Let’s remember he’s told us before that Joe Schmidt should be sacked, Tommy Bowe isn’t quick enough for international rugby, Johnny Sexton isn’t good enough to be Ireland’s 10 and countless other buffoon moments.

    He’s the Dunphy of rugby, but at least Dunphy knows what he’s on about.

    Reply
    • Listen to Hook on the radio, you will discover an intelligent, insightful and very knowledgeable man. I for one respect his views and analysis, though I don’t always agree.
      I can see from your comment hat you are another clueless band-wagon Leinster fan, since the majority of your grievances are about that province.
      Grow up and remember that man has forgotten more about rugby, than a clown like you will ever know!

      Reply
  • Conor O’Shea for Munster/Ireland coach some day!?

    Reply
  • Paul you have lost any credibility you might have had as a rugby writer. George Hook is constantly wrong in his views, and most of the time he is speaking just to be Controversial. He is a disgrace of a pundit, and most rugby fans are sick of him and wish he would go away. Horgan is top notch with O shea and Quinlan. Pope is a nice guy but his views are normally in response to another silly statement from George Hook.

    Reply
    • That’s pretty harsh Richard, especially as it’s essentially a fun, colour piece. Whether you agree or disagree with Hook (and I often disagree), he’s generally pretty entertaining to watch and RTE’s viewing figures compared with the BBC indicate I’m not alone in thinking that.

      Reply
    • Paul those viewing figures are not as a result of hook being on board, if he left the viewers would go up. I would take keith wood and guscott over hook and pope any day. The man as become ridiculous, for over a year he ridiculed the choice of Sexton as the irish outhalf. …bill o herlihy and horgan, Quinlan, are well worth a watch. Hook is just a failed bitter coach with tired views.

      Reply
    • Completely agree, Hook is the main reason I would not watch RTE for rugby coverage, I only turn it on when the game is in for reviews at half time and full time I stick on bbc, it’s gone beyond being a joke now and he should be rid of, that skit himself and pope did of making breakfast the mourning the rugby world cup started was a disgrace and the last time I watch there pre and post match coverage, it’s a pity because Conor o’shea is the best pundit on tv at the moment, also Ryle nugent is possible the best rugby commentator since fred cogley, biting can be as bad as George Hamilton

      Reply
  • Horgan is quality. Reminds me of Garry Neville, people may not like him, but talks a lot is sense.

    Reply
  • Conor O’Shea is superb and hopefully future Irish head coach.
    Hook is a clown and real turn off.
    One to look out for is Dean Ryan who is actually helping out Scotland this year; he is so incisive and full brilliant analysis.

    Reply

Add New Comment