N.B. THIS LIST IS based on players’ careers overall rather than on what they specifically achieved in the MLS. In addition, only players who have literally played in the MLS are eligible, hence the exclusion of Frank Lampard, Kaka, Pele, George Best et al.
13. Obafemi Martins (Seattle Sounders)
A fine player at his peak, featuring prominently at Inter for a couple of seasons before enjoying a decent spell with Newcastle. He is now impressing in the MLS for the Seattle Sounders.
12. Landon Donovan (San Jose Earthquakes, LA Galaxy)
A US legend, Donovan has thrived in the MLS for much of his career. Had he experienced similar success in Europe, he’d undoubtedly be higher on this list.
11. Tim Howard (MetroStars)
Showed his class at the 2014 World Cup, where he almost single-handedly kept the US in games at times (particularly against Belgium). Howard has been a regular at Everton for a number of seasons, but played for MetroStars (now New York Red Bulls) earlier in his career.
10. Clint Dempsey (New England Revolution, Seattle Sounders FC)
Consistently an integral member of the US team, Dempsey spent his best years in the Premier League with Fulham, in addition to having a brief spell at Tottenham. His career has been bookended by stints in the MLS, while he recently returned to Fulham on loan.
9. Marco Di Vaio (Montreal Impact)
Featuring for a number of illustrious clubs including Juventus, Valencia and Parma, Di Vaio was undoubtedly a top player on his day. He also enjoyed a late career renaissance in the MLS, scoring 34 goals in 76 appearances for Montreal Impact, before retiring last year.
8. Jermaine Defoe (Toronto FC)
A phenomenally prolific goalscorer of the Premier League era, Defoe has scored well over 100 times in England’s top flight. He now plays for Toronto FC, though rumours of a return to Britain persist.
7. Brad Friedel (Columbus Crew)
Arguably the best American goalkeeper ever, Friedel represented his country at three World Cups and starred in the Premier League for well over a decade (he is even still officially a Tottenham player). Before gaining renown in England, he was impressing Stateside with Columbus Crew.
6. Tim Cahill (New York Red Bulls)
One of the players partially responsible for Everton’s largely excellent form under David Moyes, the goalscoring midfielder now plies his trade at New York Red Bulls, and enjoys similar levels of success.
5. Robbie Keane (LA Galaxy)
Ireland’s record goalscorer’s Premier League exploits tend to be somewhat marred by his disappointingly short stint at Liverpool, but for years, he was a key player for a Tottenham side chasing Champions League football. He has enjoyed a new lease of life in America after an ill-fated second spell at Spurs, featuring in the MLS Team of the Year for the last three consecutive seasons, in addition to claiming countless other accolades.
4. Freddie Ljungberg (Seattle Sounders FC, Chicago Fire)
One of the more underrated members of the famous Arsenal ‘Invincibles’ side, Ljungberg racked up over 200 appearances for Arsene Wenger’s men in total, winning plenty of silverware in the process. He then featured for both Seattle Sounders FC and Chicago Fire during the twilight of his career.
3. David Beckham (LA Galaxy)
Often gets knocked owing to his obvious appetite for publicity, irrespective of any off-field issues, Beckham was a superb player at his peak. He was a hugely important part of Man United’s treble winners, and helped grow the game in America thereafter, in the process winning over some initially skeptical LA Galaxy fans with a series of fine displays.
2. Roberto Donadoni (MetroStars)
Perhaps the first truly legendary player to come to the MLS since its formation in 1993, Donadoni was a key part of the great AC Milan side of the late 80s and early 90s, while also featuring in the Italy squads that went agonisingly close to triumphing in two consecutive World Cups (1990 and 1994). He had a brief but memorable stint at MetroStars, before returning for a second spell at Milan.
1. Thierry Henry (New York Red Bulls)
Arguably the greatest Premier League player ever, Henry finished his career at the New York Red Bulls. Like Beckham before him, Henry’s move was a major coup for the MLS, with other once-world-class players subsequently following his lead.
A few others worth a mention
Alessandro Nesta (Montreal Impact)
Rafael Marquez (NY Red Bulls)
Cuauhtemoc Blanco (Chicago Fire)
Hristo Stoichkov (DC United)
Lothar Matthaus (Metrostars)
Darren O’Dea (Toronto FC) !!
Stoichkov should be in top three
The only thing I can think of looking at this is what would happen if you took Tim Howards beard, Brad Friedels hair and put them on Freddies face?
Juninho
Surely kaka makes that list?
Keep in mind the first two sentences of this piece. Kaka is not eligible because he has yet to play in the MLS.
..my bad
Was going to say george best but then checked when mls was founded!! But I said I would say it anyway
The legend that is Ronnie O’Brien….
Surprised Bradley Wright Philips didn’t make your list. He was the top goal scorer this season with 27 goals in 32 matches for New York.
Just read the Pre-text..scratch my comment:)
Joey Lapira
never played mls, i dont think
Carlos Valadrama
Pele?
Surely beckham should be number 1 the for number of trophies won in mls and his sheer amount of previous around the world , Thierry is a amazing player but got a champions league medal for half season at Barcelona but a well deserved World Cup medal haha it’s a hard one but beckham for me haha
Brad friedels jersey!!!usa 94
Can we have a Top 12 Players List from League Two or the SPL…..since we’re on the pub league theme?