The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 18 °C Wednesday 19 June, 2013

Poll: Who would you pick as Ireland captain?

Who’s man enough for the job?

Image: INPHO

DESPITE GOOD REPORTS of Paul O’Connell’s fitness yesterday, it still seems likely that Declan Kidney will choose to take the burden of captaincy off the second row’s shoulders for this game.

That means a new man will be asked to hold a cuddly toy and hold the mascot’s hand as the team is led from the tunnel.

For many, Jamie Heaslip is clearly the heir to the throne, but recent noises from Carton House – including Kidney’s assertion that captaincy experience at Provincial level was not an essential requirement for the job – have pointed to fly-half Jonathan Sexton and his famously inspirational half time team talks.

Outside of Leinster, many feel that Peter O’Mahony or Donnacha Ryan could lead the team as a long-term option. A category Stephen Ferris may also have fallen into before injury robbed him from this run of games.

However, as this is a temporary measure with both O’Connell and Brian O’Driscoll due back for the Six Nations; perhaps Kidney would be keen on rewarding a loyal servant. A golden handshake to either Donncha O’Callaghan or Gordon D’Arcy.

Why not Mike Ross?

So, presuming the job won’t go to O’Connell (he’ll lead the team regardless), you tell us.


Poll Results:












Guinness Series: Ryan hoping to knock the stuffing from the Springboks

Northern lights: Meyer ‘concerned’ by South African exodus to Ireland

  • Share on Facebook
  • Email this article
  •  

Read next:

Comments (19 Comments)

  • How can DOC be a choice for captain, when he will only start if Ryan or POC are injured?

    Reply
  • I would have thought that it’s nailed on O’Connell to be honest, why wouldn’t you have him as captain?
    Where are you getting the idea that he won’t captain I wonder Sean?

    Reply
  • Chris do you do anything else besides slander Munster players.. seriously nearly 70% of your comments are something negative against Munster.. then if someone says something pro Munster, you label them biased… DOC has captained the lions, more than capable of captaining his country.. he has played very well this year and if he starts it’s well deserved

    Reply
    • Sorry it’s not just their players I’m not fond of their brand of rugby, lots of their fans, that ex-coach that’s destroying the Irish team, I could go on but in all honesty when people say that DOC should captain Ireland I can’t help myself. If anyone thinks that Doc would make a better captain of Ireland than Leo Cullen when BOD and POC are not playing then I’m sorry that’s just bias. nI don’t believe that either are good enough for to play for Ireland. nMunster have some fine players and some very good young players and as an Irish fan I’d love to see these players come through but only when they are ready. I believe that Conor Murrary was not ready to start at the world cup and if Reddan was left at 9 ( and sexton at 10 ) we would have beaten Wales. nThings like Earls saying he wants to play 13 when he’s our best winger annoys me. nIf Irish rugby was in a better place it might not piss me off so much but kidney’s a joke. nn

      Reply
  • I agree POC is the sensible call, but if its true Zebo is playing at FB maybe this is the start of the future for Ireland and maybe Deccie has decided to nominate his future captain now?

    Reply
    • If Zebo gets the nod at full back I’m giving serious consideration to setting fire to my ticket, and I’m a Munster man.

      Reply
    • mattoid 07/11/12 #

      Ronan – are you expecting him to be playing at maximum potential when he’s only just out of the Munster academy?

      Players like Zebo have huge ability and potential, as you would know if you’ve seen him play at under-age, but they need the experience of playing at the top level to maximise that potential and become polished as a player.

      All rugby legends had to start somewhere!

      Reply
    • I’m not arguing about his potential. I simply don’t want one of the weakest tacklers (if not the weakest) in the Irish squad played at full back, out of position.

      We’ve been here before with Earls at 15. I don’t want kids stuffed into the team out of position for the sake of experience, and having the confidence knocked out of them. The best place for a kid to step up to international level is in their position of choice.

      I bloody hate this notion of backline cover, when there’s depth and talent in most positions waiting to be tried out.

      Zebo is a massive talent, and he’ll be great. I just don’t want to see him played out of position and made a fool of. His defensive positioning on the wing is questionable, but improving, and I don’t think he’s right for 15.

      FYI: I’ve seen footage of him at underage on youtube and games involving him on TG4. As it happens, I went to CBC and so I stick on a bit of Munster schools rugby on the tv.

      I didn’t say I had a problem with Zebo playing, I said I had a problem with him playing at full back. This is Kidney nonsense and I’m stick of it.

      Reply
  • If he is such an obvious choice, why is he not Munster captain?? lol. All joking apart it probably will be POC but i just have a suspicion that DK might surprise us….

    Reply
    • Doc ” lads stop giving away stupid penalties will ya”
      Rest of Irish team ” eh captian your the one giving them away”
      Doc ” I know I know but that what captain’s say isn’t it, well that’s all they ever say to me anyway ”
      rest of the team ” right leave him over there and we’ll talk about tactics”

      Reply
  • ivy mike 07/11/12 #

    birdseye at this stage

    Reply
  • Wellity wellity, looks like this was relevant after all!
    Heaslip by a country mile in that case.

    Reply
  • Sexton is too vocal for captain. Screams at his own players a but much for captain. POC will be captain, if he’s not fit then Heaslip will be.

    Reply
  • POC injured? Surely he’s the obvious choice

    Reply

Add New Comment