The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 11 °C Saturday 18 May, 2013

Opinion: Regrets? Leinster will have a few after early Euro exit

Ulster and Munster march on but they’ll be up against it in the Heineken Cup knock-out stages.

Wave goodbye: Leinster's head coach Joe Schmidt.
Wave goodbye: Leinster's head coach Joe Schmidt.
Image: INPHO/Dan Sheridan

Reproduced with permission from Whiff of Cordite

THE CHAMPIONS ARE out of Europe at the pool stages.  If that sounds pretty ignominious, then it probably is.

Sure, there were mitigating circumstances in a hefty injury list and a tough pool, but them’s the breaks and they weren’t the only team with injured players or good teams to contend with.

It’ll be especially gut-wrenching that the team to edge them out of the knockouts are their arch rivals, Munster, a team they would believe themselves to be better than.

Harlequins will be happier to be facing Munster than a rejuvenated Leinster that has belatedly sparked into life since getting a proper backline on the pitch.

But, hey, that’s Heineken Cup rugby.

Leinster can at least console themselves that they kept up their half of the bargain by securing the 10 match points they needed in the final two rounds.  That they did so in a swashbuckling style reminiscent of the last two seasons is reason enough to believe that they are not a busted flush yet, and that  their premature exit should not be seen as a serious demise.  But to be entering the final rounds relying on the middle-tier French clubs for favours – especially once their own fates have been sealed – is never going to be a recipe for success.  Leinster have only themselves to blame.

While it’s tempting to look at the possibility that they left a few tries out there against both Scarlets and Exeter, in truth the damage was done in rounds one to four.  Again, many will look to the double-header with Clermont, but given the backline Leinster had out in both games (Goodman at 12, and every other player from 11-15 playing out of their best position) and the nature of Clermont’s sense of unfinished business, it is understandable that they should lose both games.

Just one more point would have left Leinster’s fate in their own hands, and the opening week fiasco, where they sleepwalked to a fortuitous, tryless win over an Exeter which conceded seven tries at home to Clermont the following week was the one that got away.  To look at it more thematically, Leinster will rue that a misfiring lineuot proved expensive right through the pool stages.

Northern exposure

No such concerns on the face of it for Ulster, but in having to go away to Saracens, they have made their possible passage to the final more difficult than it should have been.  They, too, will have cause for regret, in particular in taking their eye off the ball against Northampton in round four.

Having slaughtered the Saints in Franklin’s Gardens it looks as if Ulster may have got a bit carried away with themselves in the build-up to the return leg, and paid a heavy price.  Even still, a single extra point would have reversed the quarter-final match venue and as such, the awful third quarter in which they allowed Glasgow to dominate in Pool 5 left them one try short of what would have been a crucial bonus point.

By contrast, Munster will reflect that they are happy to be still in the competition after somehow squeezing out of a pool in which they never really impressed.

They can look back on the 10-minute salvage operation against Edinburgh at home as the point that made all the difference to their campaign.  With one try on the board after 70 minutes, it looked set to be a disappointing afternoon at Thomond Park, but Paddy Butler’s introduction provided a spark and they manufactured three tries in the dying minutes, against admittedly hapless opposition.

They’re unlikely to do much in the knock-out stages, where the Anglo-French axis look set to dominate, but how Leinster must envy them.

Read more at Whiff of Cordite

Elwood plans February league climb after Heineken Cup swansong

Read next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • Difficult to see Clermont not making the final with a home quarter and semi final.

    Reply
  • No excuses we didn’t make it, we get a crack at the amlin so let’s go for it. We’re in the top 4 in the league so that’s a real target.
    A much as I like winding up Munster fans I really hope one of the Irish teams win the cup, for Irish rugby’s sake and it would be great for the Westie’s too.
    Good luck to both Munster and ulster.

    Reply
  • As a Munster fan I am obviously delighted that once again Munster have reached the knock out stages and believe that Harlequins at the Stoop is a game that could go either way. But regardless of who wins that encounter it is unlikely that they can win away in France. If Ireland is going to win a European trophy this year it will be Leinster in the Amlin. And I will be cheering them on.

    Reply
    • Fair play Mr. Common Sense, good to see not all comments have to be negative. Disrespect on both sides is flying the last few days, I was surprised at the amount and speed of gloating on the Leinster rugby FB page yesterday!! We really only have ourselves to blame for not making it out of the pools but that’s sport……I will still love and support them. Best of luck and although you say it is unlikely you will go all the way in sport you just never know and if ye can’t do maybe Ulster can. I have tickets so I’m hoping for at least one Irish team in the final :-)

      Reply
  • Paddy 21/01/13 #

    Get a grip Richard. Don’t be posting silly arguments. Just learn to accept and move on with your life

    Reply
  • Agreed.

    Reply
  • “Harlequins will be happier to be facing Munster than a rejuvenated Leinster that has belatedly sparked into life since getting a proper back-line on the pitch”.
    Could the writer of the above comment, taken from the article, please tell me where he got this little gem of information?
    I don’t see it referenced anywhere, did Conor O Shea say it? Did anybody at Harlequins say it? Or is it as I suspect, ‘a pearl of wisdom’ pulled out of thin air!

    Reply
    • “Munster is one of the great teams that have set the standard that all others aspire to in the Heineken Cup. The province has vast experience in the tournament having reached the knock-out stages on numerous occasions and they are previous champions. They will bring that pedigree and their great rugby-playing tradition to The Stoop. They will also bring great support so Harlequins and its supporters are assured of a truly memorable occasion.” – Conor O Shea
      Above is something that was actually said, if you want to impart your vast knowledge, maybe start the sentence with- In my opinion….!

      Reply
    • Agreed, but the bitter taste of Munster getting one over Leinster will last for a long time. This article just sums up how bad Leinster fans have become. Just because they had a quality French side in their group doesn’t mean they can downgrade munster’s achievement. They had an average welsh and English team in their group too! Quit the negativity! Get some perspective in your next Article! Fair play to Ulster and Munster and best of luck to Leinster in the Amlin

      Reply
  • Fair dues to munster
    We had our injuries too
    Leinster team getting on. Need changes
    Enjoy Amlin Cup

    Reply
  • We got 9 points out of our first three matches. It could so easily have been 10.

    The nature of the injuries we faced was extreme. We had basically the first and second choice backline out at the same time.

    I also feel there was a lack of urgency in Leinster in the first two games, like we didn’t believe we’d lose both games against Clermont.

    Irony of ironies, though: Munster would have been better served dropping into the Amlin and chasing that, as they are now in a situation where they must beat Harlequins (quite unlikely) or be a second Tier European side next season!

    Reply

Add New Comment