The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 6 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

As it happened: Munster v Cardiff Blues, RaboDirect PRO12

Musgrave Park is the venue as Munster entertain the Cardiff Blues in Saturday night’s RaboDirect PRO12.

It’s sixth against eighth in the RaboDirect PRO12 as Munster entertain Cardiff Blues at Musgrave Park.

We’d love to hear your thoughts on the game. E-mail tony@thescore.ie, tweet @thescore_ie, post a message to our Facebook wall, or leave a comment below.

Full-Time: Munster 6-17 Cardiff Blues

19.41 – After Munster suck in the Cardiff defence, Felix Jones plays the ball out to Mike Sherry. The move breaks down and Cardiff break.

The ball runs the length of the field and Rhys Patchell denies HIMSELF a clear try when his indecision on the line allows the home side to clear.

20.03 – A drop goal attempt from Patchell goes right and wide, but a decent effort nonetheless.

Munster have shown signs of their best form, but they’ve been all too fleeting. A poor match so far.

20.13 – After Munster earn a scrum a couple of metres from the Cardiff line, Earls feels the ball to Felix Jones. Munster switch the play again with O’Donnell and O’Gara but the former goes out of play and the lineout is Cardiff’s.

It’s a spirited display from Munster but everything about this display is predictable.

20.16 – What can I tell you? It’s been an abysmal game. “Dour and disappointing. We need a spark at Musgrave Park.” according to Ryle ‘Ryle Nugent’ Nugent.

We certainly do.

Anyway, that’s half-time, the scores are level, I’m off for a little daydream where I’m in the pub and none of this is happening. Back shortly.

20.30 – The match is back underway, and Munster take the initiative before Donnacha Ryan’s casual handling gives the advantage to Cardiff.

20.34Try for Cardiff Blues!

Finally, finally, we have a try. Munster fall asleep and Owen Williams takes advantage of a sweet, economic piece of play to race clear of the home defence and score the try. Patchell with the extras.

20.50 – Jason Tovey and Lou Reed come off for Cardiff, with James Down and Leigh Halfpenny coming on in their place.

Billy Holland replaces Dave Foley for Munster, as Old Ryle describes the action on the pitch as a “collective malfunction.”

20.55 – Ralph Keyes points out that Munster have not created one serious try scoring opportunity. He’s right too.

A Munster scrum raises the temperature slightly at the moribund stadium, and the home side works the ball from one side to the other and back, without really making any headway.

Credit to Cardiff, who have defended magnificently.

As it happened: West Ham v Manchester United, FA Cup 3rd >

Read next:

Comments (51 Comments)

  • absolutely chronic rugby . commentator said its insipid & uninspiring rugby ! he’s being nice . hopefully 2nd half Will be better

  • Amateur performance out of Munster tonight — and it’s hard to admit that, as a fan. Awful handling and seemingly no idea how to attack other than spreading it wide? Hate to say it but on nights like this it just seems like Munster don’t have the calibre of players.
    Hanrahan and Keatley desperately needed (though ROG had a good game). It looks like we’re just way behind Ulster and Leinster in terms of bringing younger players through.

  • I am a Leinster supporter but am surprised at the anti-Munster comments particularly from their own supporters? Every bounce of the ball went Cardiff?s way. It can happen and that is why Rugby is such a great game, fate plays a part? The last team in the world to write off is Munster.

    • Well said Brian, I’m a Leinster fan too and I don’t like to see Munster lose. They’re an Irish team simple as that. I hope we both qualify for the next round for the HC.

  • I nearly kicked the tv in after watching that.. If we want to progress Keatly needs to be given the chance to play in pressure situations .. penny needs to make the decision, grow a pair…. Laluala is not fitting either, get jj in at 12 as soon as possible

  • sparky 05/01/13 #

    Awful performance hopefully they’ll get a shoe up the hole Monday morning to wake them up. What’s up with all the Leinster commentators here? lads ye’re match was last night and ye won fair play, Munster didn’t you’d swear Leinster never lost a match before

  • What has happened to Munster rugby?if this was soccer munsters coach would not have a job tomorrow ,

  • Wow.feel sorry to be IRiSH rugby supporter when I hear such tripe being spouted from fan to “Fan”.u such fans really need to get the fu€k over your selves regarding Munster Leinster SHITE.

    • Spot on David, whenever I meet Munster fans we have a much more supportive debate about each other’s teams. There just isn’t that football rivalry. It must be the ease at which some people can hide on social networking.

  • I didn’t get up @ 3am to watch this tripe.

  • Elrat 05/01/13 #

    Play your rugby in Limerick Munster! There is a better atmosphere in a graveyard than that MusGRAVE park!

  • The comments here make me depressed to be an irish rugby fan. A load of Leinster “supporters” acting like regular soccer supporting gobsh**es. There is such a thing as healthy rivalry. Stop trying to turn inter provincial rugby rivalry into some west London soccer derby crap! Munster were cat, Leinster are no spring chickens either. I’m just proud that its another irish team that are pipping for the best form team at the moment in Europe and that’s ulster! Get over yourselves Leinster, humility is a trait you should all learn, Munster will be back, this all moves in cycles, grow up!

    • damian 06/01/13 #

      Humility? Ha ha :-) from someone that put the word supporters in quotes to put down Leinster fans. Yeah… Good lad…

    • I don’t see any Ulster or Connaught supporters on here sniping at Munster, but if you could point them out I’ll retract my statement “lad”. The “” is to point out that anyone that has to attack a provence who is going through transition and has put down an awful display just for one man up manship is NOT a true rugby supporter! End of!

    • Don’t think that’s what I was saying Diarmaid. I couldn’t tell you who started I was simply pointing out your provincial myopia is all. But Munster fans are beyond bias too I’m sure.

    • damian 06/01/13 #

      You love those quotes….

  • LIsten up Munster. Leinster are the No 1 team in Ireland now.

    • ulster are now top.dogs u blue muppet . admit it and im a red

    • Actually Leinster is not doing to we’ll either so I wouldn’t be so smug.

    • Elrat 05/01/13 #

      Come to Thomond Park and repeat that!!

    • @John Deane

      Surely Ulster are, even the most one eyed Leinster fan can admit that. Ulster just look immense, and blew the Scarlets away last night. Top new generation of Irish players emerging.

    • What have ulster done to replace the back to back European champions then ?

      Well?

    • Duh

    • Sorry but what have ulster won? They are playing really well but until the silverware is handed out I’d still say the 3 time European champions are the best team in the country.
      As for the next generation of Irish players ulster are by far the most reliant on overseas players of all the provinces.

    • Elrat 05/01/13 #

      Your back to back Lonster team won’t even qualify this year !

    • Elrat if they don’t get out I the group fair enough we can’t win it every year, one things for certain even if Munster make the knockout rounds they have no chance of winning it not a snowballs chance in hell

    • @ Chris: Jackson, Cave, Henry and Gilroy will all be playing for Ireland in the next couple of seasons. No?

      As for number 1, I am speaking about current from this season, and this season, Ulster are the top Irish province. Can this be denied? Rabo and HEC results would seem to say so.

    • Elrat 05/01/13 #

      But we will qualify AGAIN for the umpteen time

    • Nice that you have qualifying again to celebrate

      It’s probably the total that your ambition can extend to these days.

      Well done you!

    • Nobody’s saying ulster’s form is not very good but it means nothing if they don’t win something come may.
      I stand by me comment that they depend more on overseas players than any other Irish team.

    • @Chris

      Fair enough, but Leinster would have none of their Heineken Cups was it not for three players, Rocky Elsom, Nathan Hines and Brad Thorn.

    • Padraic do you really believe those 3 players won the titles on their own?
      Leinster were a 1 man team? Just happened to be a different 1 man each time.
      If anybody who saw the Northampton final believes that Hines was more important that day than sexton well really we are watching a different sport.
      Ulster are dependant on overseas players at 3, 5, 8, 9 and 15 and while you can name an Irish player who can play any of those positions for them if they are fit the overseas player will start for them.

    • @Chris.

      Of course not, but these players were the difference between winning and losing the HC for Leinster. Without these players, they would have come close, but would have ultimately most likely fallen short.

    • You can say that about most players in any winning team.
      In all honesty naming two secondrows as the reason a team becomes champions of Europe is pushing it a little.
      No doubt all 3 players had a Hugh part to play in the suscess but during all those wins O’Driscoll was constant and in the last two Sean O’Brien and then rob Kearney have been named the European player of the year.

    • @Chris

      So Leinster were not reliant on some key foreigners then? I gues Nacewa’s contribution wasn’t massive either.

      Pretty one eyed stuff Chris.

      In any case, all the provincial rugby is second fiddle to the national side, who are distinctly second rate. The HC has given Irish rugby fans a distorted sense of success whilst their national team merely wins one Championship since 1985 and has never made it past the last 8 of a world cup.

    • Elrat 06/01/13 #

      Stick to Wexford hurling !

    • @Chris

      As for your ‘In all honesty naming two secondrows as the reason a team becomes champions of Europe is pushing it a little’ comment, well, I think that you are in the minority with your opinion there.

      The reason Leinster are in the mess they are is because they do not have a functioning second row. Cullen, despite his great service in seasons gone by, is now past it, Toner isn’t good enough, and this has been widely acknowledged in Irish media, Browne clearly isn’t good enough at HC level. The likes of Hines, and Brad Thorne, had they such players this year, would have surely been the difference between winning and losing a game vs Clermont, a team where ironically Hines now plies his trade. It is no coincidence that Leinster have signed the likes of McCarthy from Connacht. The secondrow is Leinster’s Achilles heal.

      Do you disagree?

  • Is Conor Murray off or blood sub????

  • Come onnnn de blues

  • Munster Era is well and truly over..

  • Elrat 06/01/13 #

    Love the comments on Leinster v Edinburg – nothing about rugby – all about tg4 showing game. Big contrast on Munster v Cardiff where Lonster goys are making comments on the game – mostly derogatory – big chip goys !!