We were live from high in the stands at the Aviva Stadium as Scotland are in town for Ireland’s penultimate Six Nations showdown. Get in contact with your thoughts/feelings/corrections in the usual way. Find us on Facebook, tweet @thescore_ie or just shout in the comment section below.
Full-time: Ireland 32 Scotland 14
So let’s do this. Ireland and Scotland’s rugby stars are going through the motions in front of me as we’re less than 30 minutes from kick at Lansdowne Rd.
The conditions, as they say, are perfect for a game of rugby football. Brian O’Driscoll and Jerry Flannery are suited and booted on the sideline as they’re interviewed by Off The Ball’s Mark Horgan for the big screen. The seats throughout the Aviva Stadium are starting to fill up and the volume is edging ever slightly upwards.
“There’s a few knocks and bangs but that’s part and parcel of football,” says Declan Kidney to RTÉ’s Claire McNamara on the monitor in front of me. “But everyone’s looking forward to the day.” He’s not wrong there.
Let’s have your predictions.
If anyone’s planning on stealing Gavin Hastings’ identity we now know his address: cloud cuckoo land, according George Hook. The former Scotland talisman insisted moments earlier that if Scotland score a couple of tries they’ll win or something to that effect. As I type Declan Kidney, the quiet man of Irish sport, is striding away from an Irish huddle in which he was stuck in the middle, barking out final words of encouragement in the absence of BOD and POC. Good stuff.
Declan Kidney has just handed me his team-sheet and topped up my tea. Nice one, Deccie. Here’s those starting XVs:
Scotland: S Hogg; L Jones, N De Luca*, G Morrison, S Lamont ; G Laidlaw, M Blair; A Jacobsen, R Ford (capt), G Cross, R Gray, J Hamilton, J Barclay, R Rennie, D Denton.
Replacements: S Lawson, E Murray, A Kellock, R Vernon, C Cusiter, R Jackson, M Evans.
Ireland: R Kearney; T Bowe, K Earls, G D’Arcy, A Trimble; J Sexton, E Reddan; C Healy, R Best (capt), M Ross, D O’Callaghan, D Ryan, S Ferris, P O’Mahony, J Heaslip.
Replacements: S Cronin, T Court, M McCarthy, S Jennings, T O’Leary, R O’Gara, F McFadden.
Note to self: Insert joke about golden ticket and/or playing at scrum half…
Pic: Inpho.
We’ve just had the anthems and Ireland’s Call and we’re about to kick off. Let’s do it.
Ireland 0 Scotland 3 It’s first blood, Scotland then thanks to an early penalty from Greg Laidlaw. Ireland have yet to get going though the first engagement in the scrum was probably advantage to the hosts and Cian Healy. Scotland then took a quick tap and went wide. They were called back for a forward pass when it looked like they had men and opportunities outside and the visiting No 10 made no mistake from his first effort on the posts. Is that clear?
First line out of the evening after Keith Earls threw in a massive challenge on Evans, forcing the ball loose as Scotland were again on the front foot.
Ireland 0 Scotland 6 And that first line-out is botched and Scotland roar forward again, as has been the pattern over the course of the first 11 or 12 minutes here. Gordon Darcy was then adjudged to have come in from the side and Laidlaw arrowed it over for another three points. The crowd around us are attempting to lift their own performance too after a pretty quiet opening period.
TRY! Ireland 7 Scotland 6: What a response from Ireland. Stand-in skipper Rory Best told Jonny Sexton to kick for touch rather the posts and the brave decision paid off when he took an offload from Keith Earls, dropped the shoulder on Mike Blair, drove over the line and touched down himself. Jonny Sexton then adds the conversion points despite Lamont charging out and kicking downfield. He got another go and made no mistake with an excellent effort.
Ireland showed a lot of patience to go through plenty of pick and rolls, metres from the Scottish line. Reddan almost wriggled through at one stage but was stopped by Denton. Ultimately, the home side were penalised for hanging on to the ball and the pressure is eased for Andy Robinson’s outfit. “At least now both sides will know hwat is expected of them from the referee,” Donal Lenihan says from the gantry here in the west stand. 25 minutes gone now.
Ireland 10 Scotland 9 That’s a weird one. Scotland were piling on the pressure within Ireland’s five-metre line. The Irish defence was fracturing, Rory Best was told his players were on the brink of a yellow card and then the visitors decide to kick for the posts. They’ll feel they had to get something for their efforts, but the supporters here will be happy to concede just three.
TRY! Ireland 17 Scotland 9 (Eoin Reddan 32′) After Laidlaw kicked that penalty effort, Ireland reclaimed the restart, Scottish players flooded past the tackle line, the Leinster scrum half reversed past them and made for the line unopposed.
So we had some technical difficulties there for a second or so… as did Ireland’s defence. This is what happened, as Scotland earned a try, according to The Guardian: “Gray bombs through a couple of tackles down the left. Bowe’s in front of him, but Gray sells him a dummy to the left, drops a shoulder to slip to Bowe’s right, and tears across the tryline. Wonderful solo play.” So there.
TRY Ireland 22 Scotland 14 (Andrew Trimble 40′) The final action of the half is Jonny Sexton kicking his first missed punt at goal of the first 40. Ireland go in with an eight-point cushion thanks to a try from the Ulster man in the dying moments. Rob Kearney first threatened before the ball ultimately came to Trimble and he finished — in no small part thanks to poor Scottish defending — right in the corner.
So, what did you make of that then? Are Ireland clinical with ball in hand or are Scotland’s defence making them look good?
Jonny Sexton gets us underway as the sky darkens and Shipping Up To Boston rings in our ears. More of the same would be nice.
TMO! Tommy Bowe collects a cross-field kick after a magnificent passage of play from Ireland. The Ospreys man landed on his back and had to battle to turn and touch down. He grounds it but the question is about the movement I suppose. What do you think?
NO TRY The TMO decides Bowe did in fact make two movements and a penalty is awarded. That would have been a record-equalling sixth try for the Monaghan winger in this championship. We’re enduring a break in play meanwhile as the ref’s communication system is sorted out.
Tom Court trots on to deputise for Cian Healy, who is off down the tunnel with a blood injury, There’s now 51 minutes on the clock. I’m exhausted.
Tomás O’Leary, O’Gara and Sean Cronin have been introduced together in place of Darcy, Reddan and the skipper Best respectively. Sexton will go to 12 I suppose in what should be an interesting experiment and ROG takes over the captaincy. Cian Healy, meanwhile, is back pitchside.
I’d probably be asking for trouble if I asked for your caption suggestions, when there’s visiting royalty involved. But here’s Michael D and Princess Anne in the posh seats below us.
Pic: INPHO/Morgan Treacy
By the whoever had 57 minutes in the Fields of Athenry sweepstakes, please collect your prize at the top of the hall. The crowd have just given it its first airing of the evening.
Very, very worrying scenes. Lee Jones is on the ground, out cold, after a clash of heads with Andrew Trimble. Scotland were on the front foot for the first time in this half; Jones took a pass that was slightly behind him and as he did, the Ulster man crashed in at full throttle. Jones was out cold as he fell to the turf and landed heavily, obviously. He’s now receiving medical attention. In the meantime, Shane Jennings is introduced for Peter O’Mahony.
Cian Healy concedes a penalty for not releasing after a sustained period of Irish pressure. Kearney, Cronin and O’Gara all threaten as the home side search for a fourth try and the win but it comes to naught. Some good momentum after that injury lull however.
PENALTY! Ireland 25 Scotland 14 Jonny Sexton puts that extra bit of daylight between the sides with a lovely kick from a difficult angle. Ronan O’Gara had a word in his ear too, beforehand. Class.
YELLOW CARD! Max Evans trudges off to the sin bin. Rob Kearney broke from the halfway line, fed Earls outside him on the wing. Then… Evans was adjudged to have interfered with the Munster player when he kicked the ball on. “Keith Earls made the most of it,” says Donal Lenihan, “But the red card was justified.” What do you think?
TRY! Ireland 30 Scotland 14 Fergus McFadden was introduced for his Leinster team-mate Rob Kearney moments ago and he’s made an immediate impact with his third international try. It took him two attempts but he eventually ducked in next to the base of the post. Good stuff.
Pleasantly surprised with that team selection. Great to see Lowry get a chance. Would have liked to have seen Coombes or Timoney and Carty on the bench over Sexton/Conan as we know what they can do. Pretty sure Baloucoune, Conway, Ryan all have knocks, weren’t training anyway. Great to see Lowe back after his impressive last few months. People like to not like him but he offers something we don’t have, a savage left boot (only option in squad) and and the KBA- spoke about by ROG is prominent throughout the 80 mins. Him, Carbery, Hansen, Lowry and Ringrose all playmakers which is a real plus. Italy will struggle to cope. Ireland by 35…
@Stanley: good call with team selection except Lowe .
@Stanley: O’Mahoney really shouldn’t be playing this type of game. Everyone already know what he brings, which is very little. Should have tried someone like coombes there.
@Dave Moran: need a bit of balance and a leader for the troops. His experience will help the other lads settle in on the pitch, and he’s a great captain. He’s not in the plans long term but he’s a savage option for this game
@Sean Barry: talk to someone it will help
@Dave Moran: So O’ Mahoney brings very little. Take off those blue tinted glasses.
@Dave Moran:….sorry, disagree….we know what we missed vs France , experienced leadership….worth his place for that.
@Dave Moran: and you as a self proclaimed English man shouldn’t be commenting on here
@Sean Barry: the guy says he’d rather see Coombes ahead of O’Mahony and you say he has blue tinted glasses. Either you haven’t a clue what you’re taking about or you flew into a Munster rage without reading the full reply.
@Sean Barry: keep posting mate. It’s guys like you who have told Lowry his whole career he won’t make it. Currently a nominee for European player of the year and now an international.
@Sean Barry: lol, the lad that will probably bag a hat-trick in the same match, yeah terrible selection.
@Dave Moran: Haven’t been O’Mahony’s biggest fan but he has been playing out of his skin since last autumn. If people can’t see that they are actively choosing not to. Also, given the poor decision making 2 weeks ago, leadership is an issue for this group.
Baird and Treadwell is a bit of a concern in terms of 2nd row options. We look light there.
Great to see Lowry and Sheehan start. They deserve a shot. Great to see Hume, Casey and Kilcoyne involved too. Kilcoyne definitely a better bench option than Healy
@Dave Moran: I’m Leinster through and through but in fairness to O Mahoney he is playing great ball these days. He is a senior player and has massive experience. He deserves his place in the squad, it’s only a pity that by him being there Coombes misses out on the experience but you can have it every way
@Eoin Roche: And miss three tackles in return
@Stanley: I agree. POM will first of all help a line out composed of two locks who’ve never played together before. But also he is an excellent leader. Personally as a Leinster man I think he’s underrated by many Ireland fans outside of Munster. Only real issue I have is id like to have seen Coombes start but all in all I think this is the right team for this game.
@Sean Barry: I suppose you would have went for Zebo??
@Emmet Martin: re POM, agreed that he’s been playing well, but is he going to be around for the World Cup? His experience got him sent off V wales and he got dropped from the squad for the lions. Would have preferred coombes & Carty instead of Conan & sexto. Nice to see Lowry, Lowe and henshaw start. Green Tinted glasses
@Sean Barry: is coombes heading to Dublin as part of the Jenkins deal?
@Dave Moran: Coombes is a number 8
@Pete Slattery ✏️: To add to the mix I would prefer to see Coombes ahead of Conan on the bench. Jack has been very poor in the last two games.
@Sean Barry: Jim? Is that you?
@Will: zebo Well passed it. Lamour all day long.
@Jeremy Kilpatrick: being nominated isn’t quiet the achievement people make … Jimmy O’Brien is nominated too.
@Danger: yes, O’Mahony probably will be in the Irish squad for RWC. Don’t think that’s particularly far fetched? He’ll be just turning 34. Will probably be captain for some of the easier pool games.
@Emmet Martin: I hope not. He won’t be in the 23 for the big games. Why bring someone who is not pushing for selection for the 23?
@whoowhat?: a touch of dictatorship with that comment, ign0rant at best.
@Dave Moran: Line-out. You have a new hooker starting and with him you need an experienced leader calling the the throws. Also Baird’s first start and POM gives us another option in the line-out. Horses for courses. Great balance in the forwards. Good call by Farrell.
@Dave Moran: very little? You clearly know f all about rugby
@Dave Moran: Cop yourself on, O’Mahony brings very little ? Ridiculous Leinster type comment, put on your bloody green jersey and not the blue one, no wonder Leinster are despised outside the M50.
@Emmet Martin: Treadwell is 6ft 7 & 18.5 stone. Not exactly light haha
Congratulations to Michael Lowry, well deserved.
@Bob Cummings: has the potential to be a 10. Cracking footballer
Great to see Mike Lowry in there. He has been genuinely thrilling to watch at times this season. TV does not do justice to his acceleration.
@Justin Robinson: when he opens his legs, do you get excited?
@Danger: perv
Happy enough with this selection, great chance for carbery to try stake his claim . Delighted fo Lowry , he’s been amazing for ulster since he came in . Hopefully he can bring that same intent to the national squad . Would have liked to see Hume starting this one though , we are all very familiar with the other midfield combinations.
Very harsh on Larmour considering Hansen is primarily a left wing and wouldnt be played there against any top nation. Farrell clearly not a fan even though he has been in good form. Excited to see Lowry in full back..
@Dave Moran: labour over Lowe any day.
@Sean Barry: keep dreaming have u not watched Lowe this season
@Dave Moran: Last time they met Hansen have a lovely try that involved an unfortunate a$$ to face tackle technique from Larmour… Bruising, ego wise
@thesaltyurchin: was that the game Hansen made a fantastic try saving tackle on Dan Shehan
@Sean Barry: ‘labour over Lowe any day.’ well they are both supposed to be left wingers
@Dave Moran: crying a river that there ANY non Leinster players in an Irish rugby team
@Dave Moran: there’s enough leinster players on I’d say. Larmour hasn’t performed in a green Jersey. He had his chance
Glorious! Christmas has come early ^^*
Only one missing for me is Robert Baloucoune
@GrassHopper: he’s injured
Looking at the bench, Farrell must be looking to move Carbery to fullback if lowery needs to come off.
Exciting experimental team here.
@Aaron Tynan: Hansen or Henshaw can also cover full back. Lowry can also cover 10 and I would expect to see him offering himself as an option in the 10 channel as the game progresses.
Down to 12 Leinster International picks this time prefer to see Harry Byrne twiddling his thumbs rather than wasting Jacks time again. France is beckoning
Great to see Lowry getting a start
With six changes (plus 1 positional) from the team that started against France, anything other than a comfortable bonus point win and Farrell risks being very conservative in his future selections.
Just asking what Treadwell is like, haven’t seen him play much, is he a ball playing or grunting forward
@Michael Hanrahan: He’s a younger, poorer, English version of Ross Moloney.
@Michael Hanrahan: He’s a mobile lock who likes to carry and get his hands free. He’s nothing like Molony, Molony is more like O’Connor.
@Sustainable Hedgehog: I meant in terms of quality. He also seems like a bit of a penalty machine? Even for Ulster I would take O’Connor ahead of him.
@Richard James: I’d take O’Connor too but I think AF selected him for his mobility, he’s more mobile than AOC and RM. And it’s a bit harsh to call him a penalty machine based on the one mad tip tackle against Munster.
@Sustainable Hedgehog: 3 penelties this season to malonys 6. Albeit Molony has played nearly twice as much. Can’t see how you can lable one a penalty machine when both are about even.
Jack Carty hard done by again