The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 17 °C Sunday 19 May, 2013

Steady as she goes: Kidney names unchanged side to face Italy

The Ireland XV which never had a chance to perform in the Stade de France will face Italy this Saturday.

Paul O'Connell at training this morning.
Paul O'Connell at training this morning.
Image: ©INPHO/Dan Sheridan

DECLAN KIDNEY IS sticking with the starting XV which he intended to field against France to do the job when Ireland host Italy this Saturday afternoon.

As expected, Keith Earls will make his first start in this year’s tournament alongside Gordon D’Arcy in midfield, while Jonny Sexton’s insistence that he has returned to full fitness sees him preferred again to Ronan O’Gara at out-half.

Sexton had an injury scare when he complained of muscle tightness in the run-up to the abandoned match in the Stade de France, but said yesterday that it was a “slight niggle” and nothing more.

Fergus McFadden, who scored all of Leinster’s points in a narrow 16-13 win against the Scarlets last Friday, is named among the replacements, as is the uncapped Peter O’Mahony.

The pack remains unchanged, with Paul O’Connell again set to captain the side from the second row.

The decision to name the same side as the abandoned France game was far from a reflex action, Kidney said at this afternoon’s team announcement.

We had a good long discussion about it and we just made sure that in our own heads we were treating this game by game and not looking at it as a block of anything.

We took a look at all the different permutations but we said to the players that we just need to treat this game by game and that’s what we’re doing.

Ireland (v Italy): Kearney; Bowe, Earls, D’Arcy, Trimble; Sexton, Murray; Healy, Best, Ross; O’Callaghan, O’Connell (c); Ferris, O’Brien, Heaslip. Replacements: Cronin, Court, Ryan, O’Mahony, Reddan, O’Gara, McFadden.

It’s back: but will Kidney make any tweaks at all?

Leinster dismiss claims that they ‘vow to fight’ for Nacewa

Read next:

Comments (19 Comments)

  • Eimz T 21/02/12 #

    Personally I’d like to see bowe and McFadden in the centre with earls and Trimble on the wings. Zebo is a serious prospect but might not be ready for international duty just yet. I’m still perplexed at D’Arcy’s inclusion in the squad.

    As for sexton, he is the future no doubt about it, but you can’t use youth or experience as an excuse for subpar performances anymore, he’s been around long enough now. I still feel that ROG is the better kicker but no doubt a liability defensively.

    O’mahony will surely get a run v Italy so that will be interesting.

    Reply
  • The whole Sexton/ROG thing is getting old, the reason Sexton looks a little ropey in an Ireland shirt is because Kidney likes to play a kicking game in the same manner as Munster! Give JS ball in hand and let him bring our QUALITY BACK 3 into play! If you want to play a kicking game for territory then yes O’Gara is the king but they’re 2 different players and we’re blessed to have quality like that! The only problem is Kidney can’t tell the difference between the two!

    Reply
  • Would have liked to see a few changes.. like maybe Ryan, O’Mahony and McFadden starting rather than on the bench.

    Reply
  • For the love of god will people drop this “sexton needs experience/confidence” argument..He is a professional rugby with a world cup ,3 6nations ,celtic leagues and hc cups runs under his belt,if he is not producing the goods then its down to him…rog gave a exhibition of rugby saturday,he is playing his best rugby to date,start him!If anything it should be Madigan or to a lesser extent Keatly they should be blooding

    Reply
    • Eimz T 21/02/12 #

      He’s the future in that ROG isn’t far from retiring and at 25/26 he has a good 5/6 years at number 10 ahead of him. I think it’s high time we learn to get behind him and hope that he does find form in the green shirt because O’Gara isn’t getting any younger. And I’m a Munster fan btw.

      Reply
    • Eimz T 21/02/12 #

      Replied to the wrong comment there, was meant as a reply to Mary, my bad!

      Reply
    • Eimz T, I don’t disagree that he is the future and that ROG is about to retire. And I do get behind him when Ireland play. I’m just sick of hearing as Gearoid pointed out the “sexton needs experience” argument…he has experience and an abundance of it, time he started showing it. Come the weekend I will like every other person in the country be shouting him on and hoping he gives the performance we know he can give

      Reply
    • Eimz T 21/02/12 #

      Completely agree with you there. It’s time that he proves himself because those excuses simply don’t stand up anymore.

      Reply
    • I really weary of this Sexton begrudgery that’s taken root in Irish rugby, and for me it’s a poison that’s really started to spoil my enjoyment of the sport. There are 14 other players on the Irish squad for you to examine, and while Sexton by no means covered himself in glory in the Wales game, he was far from the worst. Sexton gets picked at outhalf because he needs to continue to develop his game. O’Gara will not be there for the next world cup and Sexton has some work still to do to fully flesh out his game. O’Gara is a consummate kicker, but he’s defensively quite frail and on attack tends towards the predictable. I wouldn’t say that he’s a better outhalf than Sexton – on their best days it would still be hard to pick one over the other, but he definately favours a different style of play.

      Reply
  • I don’t think that’s very fair, he should be given as much time as possible in the 10 slot for Ireland and let people get behind him, BTW, ardent Munsterman. Sexton is young and struggling with consistency what he needs is a little faith, not Joe Soap screaming for ROG at every turn. He’s not going to the next world cup.

    Reply
  • Eh sexton played 10 v England in their grand slam attempt last season and then v Australia in the world cup, two of ireland best wins since our grand slam.
    Also when he left the field v Wales we were in front. Lads you need to get over it as sexton the man.

    Reply
    • Chris the same could be said about Sexton in last years six nations game against Wales. If my memory serves me right O’Gara started and we were winning until Sexton came on. I have nothing against Sexton and think he’s a good player just inconsistant especially at international level.

      For those saying Sexton is the future I’m sorry but the guy’s what 27 or just about to turn 27? he shouldn’t need to be finding his feet at that age. He should be exerpienced enough, he’s had 2 seasons at number 10 now.

      Reply
  • Why dnt form players ever play for ireland i.e zebo and ryan

    Reply
  • chris macdonnell,there is a huge diference with playing with club and country .. sexton is a prime example of that

    Reply
  • Well said Gearoid. Couldn’t agree more!

    Reply
  • No 10 given to the green choker. (if only Ireland played in blue he might be good enough then)

    Reply
  • Sexton is the best Outhalf in Europe bar none. If you want to see this watch how he plays when he had a game plan that allows him to play rather than kick up and unders. So for you Munster fans your going to have to wait until Kidneys retires or go watch a Leinster game

    Reply
  • Kidney couldn’t pick his nose

    Reply

Add New Comment