The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 12 °C Friday 24 May, 2013

Guinness Series: Kidney energised after throwing the selectorial dice

“If you are going to play the best you want them to be at their strongest,” insisted the Irish coach.

Declan Kidney has made seven changes to the Ireland team that lost 60-0 to New Zealand.
Declan Kidney has made seven changes to the Ireland team that lost 60-0 to New Zealand.
Image: ©INPHO/Dan Sheridan

THE TRAINING HAS been the best ever, there are a lot of leaders in the Ireland squad and the 60-0 reverse against the All Blacks was only a blip. Good, because I was starting to worry.

When asked to weigh up the the upcoming battle between hookers Richardt and Adriaan Strauss on Saturday, Declan Kidney gives a literal answer with a dash of humour.

“Richardt will bring his industry around the place,” he told TheScore.ie. ”His cousin [Adriaan] has a few pounds on him. In fact, the whole South African team have a few pounds on us. It’s going to be a huge challenge for him.”

Kidney’s remarks are best bracketed in the Graham Henry school of comedy but it is encouraging to see him try.

He has made seven changes from the side that were tasered into early paralysis by the All Blacks at Waikato Stadium and there are some daring selections.

New combinations, he admits, are risky but exciting.

Kidney commented, “The analysis can work in your favour too because it’s harder for them to analyse what we’re going to do and we probably don’t know it ourselves.”

Great, because I was starting to worry.

A new captain and then some

Kidney may never truly escape the accusation that he favours Munster players but he countered the promotion of Simon Zebo to fullback by making Leinster forward Jamie Heaslip his captain for the foreseeable future.

“Simon has been playing well,” said Kidney. “I see the back three as somewhat of a reversal for the front row, just different ends of the pitch, they need to play off one another they just have a bigger area of ground to cover.

“I felt that the three of them [Zebo, Andrew Trimble and Tommy Bowe] deserved their chance and I put Simon in the middle.” The Ireland coach added:

We’re fortunate in that we have a number of candidates for it but I think that he has proven that (captaincy) sits easy on his shoulders at Leinster. The one thing with captaincy is that you don’t want to be burdening a player.

“His primary job is to be a player but Jamie has shown that he can do that and captain the side as well.”

Add Mike McCarthy’s ‘right place at the right time’ promotion to the second row and the chance given to Chris Henry to stake a claim for the openside flanker position – as well as Keith Earls at 13 – and there will be enough plots and sub-plots to push RTÉ towards red-button coverage.

Donnacha Ryan and Mike McCarthy 8/11/2012

Ireland’s new second row: Donnacha Ryan and Mike McCarthy. (©INPHO/Billy Stickland)

“This is the lads’ opportunity and they know it,” said Kidney. “They’ll strive to hang onto [their jerseys] for as long as they can. I do believe that all of them have the potential to grab it and keep it.”

A couple of grievances

With Kidney revealing the grim task of assigning medical reports to assistant managers for the past five press briefings, Kevin McLaughlin and Eoin Reddan – not to mention in-form Paul Marshall – must consider themselves highly unfortunate to miss out on selection.

Referring to the decision to drop McLaughlin from the matchday 23, Kidney said, “It’s a bit of Sod’s Law sometimes as you’ll have a clutter of guys going for the one position.

It is pretty unusual that you’d have this many senior players out at the one time but it is always exciting to see new guys coming through and see what they add. Six is one of those.

“Kevin did have a good tour [of New Zealand] but I think Peter has been playing well and Chris has started the season really strongly. It is more the way they’ve been going in the last couple of weeks gives them the nod over Kevin.”

He added, “They are all tough decisions but the scrum-half one was definitely tough. We decided it would be better to start with Conor [Murray] this time, knowing we would have Eoin to come in at the right time.”

Springbok coach Heyneke Meyer has lamented the loss of his Japan-based players and injured stars like Bryan Habana but he has not fooled Kidney.

“They’ve so much to choose from really,” he remarked. “It was just a matter of who was going to get on the pitch at any one time.

“The one thing they’ve done is they’ve picked their strongest side. That is the best compliment you can have so we’re under no illusion of the size of the task we have.

“If you are going to play the best you want them to be at their strongest.”

Heaslip to lead Ireland into Bok challenge

On tour: Dan Carter is absolutely loving his trip to Scotland

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • I’m scared for them………. Go away Sean

    Reply
  • Senan 08/11/12 #

    Great article, to war my friends, with the beasts!

    Reply
  • damian 09/11/12 #

    It’s not as though he would have “thrown the selectorial dice” if there were no injuries. He had to do it… otherwise there would have been no changes and the same potential up and comers would have been with their province or holding tackle bags all week!

    Reply
  • I don’t agree with the statement that Kidney favours Munster players with regard selection and I have never heard that suggested. In my opinion Kidney is completely neutral as he is a professional to his core and is simply interested in results. If you look at team selections over the last few years, Leinster players have made up the majority of the squad which reflects the strength of Leinster. Ulster have commanded more Jerseys in the last couple of years also as they are peaking again. My only criticism of Kidney is that he may be too conservative and slow to make changes at times but he is one of the great coaches of the modern game and this selection is a real breath of fresh air. Come on Ireland!!!

    Reply
    • Sorry Dave but kidney said of Zebo’s selection in a position he had never played before ” I’ve known him since he was a kid” this stinks

      Reply
    • Kidney has placed Zebo at 15 because he believes that his strong left boot and pace will prove beneficial against the Boks style of play, which personally I agree with. The only drawback with Zebo is that his tackling isn’t great. I personally feel that this is the time to experiment with young players ahead of the the business end of the season with the six nations. Also, I believe you are incorrect with the full back positioning. I went to school a couple of years ahead of Zebo and play club rugby and I am pretty sure Zebo has togged out on numerous occasions at 15 for both PBC and Cork Constitution. I agree that it is not his preferred position but that is what November series are all about.

      Reply
  • He said it at the press conference.
    Anyway i really hope I’m wrong truly I do as I love my country and more than anything I’d like them to perform to the best our limited resources will allow but I really don’t think the direction, Methods, results that’s gone on over the past 3 years are acceptable when you consider how strong our clubs are.
    I honestly believe kidney has not got anyway near the results he should with the players we have added to that the style of rugby we play is very dull.
    Poor results with an exciting style might be acceptable or dull rugby with good results might be ok too but the results married to the way we play under kidney is just not good enough.

    methods

    Reply
    • See that’s the difference tho. People forget that our club success has been backboned by niqs. It’s only this season and last that Munster and Leinster have fielded all Irish 15′s. Not sure Ulster could do that at all….? I think Kidney needs to go but I don’t blame him alone for the dip in results…..

      Reply
    • I’m not sure Cian both leinster and Munster have had a core Irish player element when wining the hineken cup, nHaving a Cullen, Rocky, Thorne or douggie hasn’t held back Irish players I think they’ve help make them better. nThere’s a lack of movement between the provinces, jones is a good example of a player who Leinster didnt need but Munster did, makes sense for him to move. Munster have excess of secondrows leinster have to import them. nA big problem is frontrow, John Hayes been able to play for so long and never pick up injuries covered over a Hugh problem the irfu never addressed n

      Reply
  • Sean C 08/11/12 #

    The Journal’s practice of removing comments for no apparent reason and no explanation is arbitrary and lacks transparency. It also displays a lack of common courtesy to all users. Best practice is to replace deleted comments with a notice such as; “Comment removed because it breaches “x y z” of the terms if use.” (Stand by for this
    comment to disappear without trace like a Chinese dissident)

    Reply
  • lol… Except that he didnt know Zebo. DK had left schools rugby afaik by 1998, Zebo would have been about 8……

    Reply
  • Sory, hit send prematurely. Zebo got his Munster academy spot in 2008 I think so Deccie would have been gone/leaving. Its very unlikely he ever saw Zebo play at a high level while he was at Munster…

    Reply

Add New Comment