IRELAND TAKE ON France in Paris this Saturday almost certain in the knowledge that a win will secure the Six Nations Championship.
There are other permutations (like, if England lose, or win by more than 50 points then it will get really interesting) but until either of those shocks happen we’ll plan for the middle ground and try to predict what the Championship’s final game will bring.
Sean Farrell
I just can’t shake this horrible feeling.
I’ve had it since seeing Ireland reach the peak of their powers in November; then my gut-wrenching scenario was that Ireland would head to Paris looking for a Grand Slam and fall at the final hurdle.
The Slam is long gone, but the same set-up exists. Win, and the Championship is Ireland’s, but history says we’ll fumble it into someone else’s hands.
“42 years; one win, one draw,” says Brian O’Driscoll, reminding us of the woeful record in Paris. Sure we haven’t lost to Les Bleus since they sulked their way to within an inch of the World Cup, but nor have we beaten them. Twice we have met with Philippe Saint-Andre’s side at a low ebb and on both occasions we were unable to put them away despite opening up decent leads at home and away.
Joe Schmidt’s only away Test so far was a brilliant contest, but it was still a defeat. At home, Ireland have not won a close game – yes, it’s to their credit that the winning margins have been comfortable, but – clutch plays that win tight, one score games is a habit which is not evident in this side yet.
The final stages at Twickenham bore some worrying marks of a side who were a little too eager to impress. Late on, there was a big chance to slow everything down on the edge of the 22, salvage a draw and knock England out of the Championship. The chance was lost and by the time full-time comes in Stade de France on Saturday we might already be left wondering ‘what if’.
Murray Kinsella
I think Ireland are going to win in Paris because they’re a better team than France. That belief is obviously based on current form and ability, rather than history and our record in Paris, but that’s how Schmidt’s men have to think if they are to get the job done. The Kiwi is the best coach in this championship, in my opinion, and gives Ireland an advantage over the French.
In the crucial position of out-half, Ireland are going to have the better player, whether Les Bleus pick Jules Plisson, Rémi Talès. While the French are more powerful as individuals and will massively test Ireland’s defence with their running ability, I think Ireland’s superior cohesion and tactics will pull them through.
It’s going to be as evenly contested as the clash against England, but I feel Ireland will have learned from that game and find ways to pick up more scores when they visit the French 22. It’s going to take Ireland’s best performance under Schmidt, bettering what they did against the All Blacks, but they have the ability and belief to pull it off.
Pat McCarry
I am not as confident as Murray but I believe Ireland will get over the line and that Jonny Sexton will play a huge part in getting us there. The fact that Sexton has played at the stadium for Racing Métro on a couple of occasions this season is a tangible positive of his move to Paris.
The O’Driscoll factor will not be as prevalent in France but there is no doubt that his presence steels and inspires this team. If Paul O’Connell can reproduce his Welsh form (or the performance he put in for Munster against Gloucester at Kingsholm) then Ireland will be well set. The scrum and the rolling maul have been hugely impressive all tournament and did not get what they deserved at Twickenham. Let us hope that Steve Walsh rewards the dominant pack as I think it will be Ireland’s.
The niggly question marks are the French back three. I’m worried about Maxime Medard as he has been too quiet for too long. Rob Kearney is back to his best in attack but France will be looking to isolate him in defence and put balls through for Medard and Yoann Huget to chase. Let us hope that whatever kinks Kearney was working on in training this week have been solved.
The deciding factor is the Irish coaching staff and the change they have brought to a listless team. Les Kiss and John Plumtree are proving their worth — Ireland’s defence has been stingy, penalty concessions are rare and the rolling maul is an offensive bazooka. Then there’s Schmidt — a man manager who also sees the wider picture. His game-plans for all four games have been fascinating. I can’t wait to see what he comes up with against the French. I wager it will be the winning difference.
Ireland will win the 6nations and I believe the French game will be Paul O’Connell’s finest 80mins in an Irish jersey. We have a great team, great support and sheer intensity to complete the campaign.
Simple answer. Yes.
Ireland to win coz we have better players and they are playing on form. Ireland also have better management. I cannot see France winning this one.
Joe needs to bring back in O’Gara at Fly half……
Because I dont know the names of any other players and I really want to live under a bridge with all the other trolls. Sure why dont we go full hog and bring back john hayes, marcus horan, mal o kelly and loads of other retired players and just go out there and f#$/$#g hammer the french.
What about David Humphries
Claw, Keith Wood, Mick Galway, foley, quinlan, Wallace, Stringer, Rob Henderson….. All them too…. Good man!
Ya definitely Humphries, Johnny Bell, Gary Longwell, Andy Ward & Kevin Maggs too just to be safe.
I don’t understand why one of Irelands all time greats has no place in this team. Willie John McBride.
Tony Ward too.
Andy Ward
Think it could be a low scoring cagey game. Sextons kicking will be vital. Take points when we can.
Wont happen I fear.
The squad ultimately has and has always had an underdog loser mentality. In the last 10 years we have totally failed at 3 world cups, lost at least 3 championships and lost 3 easily winnable games against the All Blacks.
Before the start of this 6 nations England and France had both only won 2 more games than us but they have won 4 and 5 championships compared to our puny 1. Not enough players have been capable of following POC and BOD to victory I’m afraid.
I certainly hope Joe Schmidt rids us of this loser mentality.
You’re the one with the loser mentality. I’d hate to have a team talk from you.
Maybe you could rid us of your loser mentality and not post.
@peter, I’m a great admirer of your wit. You’ll make something of yourself one day.
Sad retort Peter.
Don’t get your knickers in a twist there, Brian. I was replying to Small retort’s post.
Loser!
An easily winnable game against the all blacks? Ya must be confusing them with another team, no such thing. Even riddled with the flu last year england had to play out of there skins to beat them
Ireland usually see their best chance the year we have England & France in Dublin.My worry is that this side have yet to win a tight game, we failed to beat NZ when we had them on the ropes and we failed to drive on and beat England when we were 10 – 3 up in the second half.
We have the team to do it but actually going out and doing it is a different matter.
Scratch the surface and I fear the same inconsistent, underachieving, low-confidence team from the last 4 years will be there.. They need a good start and calm leadership, or else the self-doubt will return and the French will grow in confidence. They were frenetic and insecure in the first half in London. A 10min try-blitz from some unforeseen French bolters and history will repeat itself.
Even if they finish level on points with England should the cup not go to the English ad they beat us in London.
They’d have an advantage as they’ve two games against too 4 at home
The six nations has it’s own unique scoring system, no bonus points. Directly from the six nations website (http://www.rbs6nations.com/en/championship/rules.php)
The RBS 6 Nations Championship Trophy is presented to the team who earn the most points during the season, with 2 points being awarded for a win, and 1 point for a drawn match.
If two or more teams finish the Championship with the same number points, the winner is decided on match-points difference (subtracting match-points ‘against’ from match-points ‘for’ in all Championship matches). If there is still no winner, then it is awarded to the team who scored the most tries during the Championship.
If after all this a winner still cannot be decided then the Championship is shared between the teams.
England will have played 2 at home. Ireland 3 at home.
True but England will have played 2 of the big 4 at home (Ireland and Wales) whereas Ireland will have played 2 of the big 4 away.
England and Ireland are the only form teams and England got that game at home.
Sean Farrell myself and your old man here in Bahrain think you couldn’t be further from the truth
Steve Walsh owes us a few generous decisions against France, he screwed us over in 2007 when we couldve won the slam!
Based on Irelands performance this season in the 6 nations we are the form side going into the Paris game. But take into account the all blacks game during the November series which in my opinion was the best 60 minutes of rugby iv seen Ireland play in my lifetime then you would have to say that this irish side are the top northern hempishre side. Yes we lost to England at Twickenham but let’s call a spade a spade we were unlucky that day. Ireland deserve to win the championship and if the french stumble bod and the boys will punish
Not really sure about being unlucky in Twickenham. I don t think we did enough to won that game , or put another way, I don t think we found away to win the game.thought sextons second hald kinda cost us dearly though I think we ll beat france if johnny plays to the level that we know he can
Without being arrogant or cocky we should be quietly confident about winning this game.
We need a huge performance but the championship is in our hands.
Once the players focus on the job at hand and not get distracted by all the other stuff then we should be fine.
It’s important that we try and take the game to France and control the tempo and pace.
If we can build phases like we did against Italy then I can see the crowd and the French players getting frustrated.
Upfront we can hopefully get an edge as our pack seems like a tighter unit than there’s.
Will be fascinating to see what game plan Schmidt takes into this one as he has had a different plan for every game so far. We were good enough to draw with France on the last 2 occasions and with the way that this squad has developed there is no reason why we can’t go one better.
The harsh lessons learned against NZ and England should help this team to get over the line on this occasion.
Can’t wait :)