The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 13 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Ireland’s injured XV: A line-up of woe and 6 Nations disasters

18 Irish players that have been knocked by injury or suspensions.

A concussed Luke Marshall is helped from the field of play.
A concussed Luke Marshall is helped from the field of play.
Image: ©INPHO/James Crombie

IRELAND FINISHED THEIR 22-15 loss to Italy with players such as Rob Kearney, Brian O’Driscoll and Jamie Heaslip on the field.

That trio were part of the 2009 Grand Slam team and have each won multiple Heineken Cups with Leinster.

A selection of others, and their Test caps, that stood, defeated, on the Stadio Olimpico pitch include Paul Marshall [1], Stephen Archer [1], Paddy Jackson [3] and Devin Toner [5].

Speaking after the loss in Rome, which ultimately left Ireland fifth in the Six Nations table, captain Jamie Heaslip said:

[It is tough], especially when you see that [flanker] Peter O’Mahony had to move to the wing for 60 minutes. That’s just what happened. You move on. It’s nothing new to us in this championship. It’s not ideal.”

Here is a starting XV of players that were either ruled out of the campaign through injury, suspended, missed matches with injuries or picked up game-ending knocks:

Loosehead: Cian Healy

Cian Healy 16/3/2013

Cited for a stamp on England’s Dan Cole. Missed the defeat to Scotland. (©INPHO/James Crombie)

Hooker: Richardt Strauss

Richardt Strauss 24/11/2012

An ankle ligament injury ended Strauss’ Six Nations bow ambitions in January. (©INPHO/Dan Sheridan)

Tighthead: Declan Fitzpatrick

Declan Fitzpatrick 25/1/2013

Coach Declan Kidney revealed the Ulster man would miss the France game through injury. (©INPHO/James Crombie)

Lock: Paul O’Connell

Paul O'Connell 4/3/2012

Underwent back surgery in December that nixed his Six Nations hopes. (©INPHO/Dan Sheridan)

Lock: Mike McCarthy

Mike McCarthy takes a break 2/2/2013

Knee ligament trouble saw him miss the Scotland match. (©INPHO/James Crombie)

Blindside: Stephen Ferris

Andrew Trimble changes his jersey after it was torn 4/3/2012

A troublesome ankle tendon injury has cut Ferris’ season short. (©INPHO/Billy Stickland)

Openside: Chris Henry

Chris Henry 24/11/2012

A cartilage tear to his right knee cut Henry’s championship campaign short. (©INPHO/James Crombie)

Number 8: Fergus McFadden

Yannick Nyanga andFergus McFadden 9/3/2013

We’re stretching here but look at McFadden (broken ribs) take on French flanker Yannick Nyanga. (©INPHO/Billy Stickland)

Scrum-half: Eoin Reddan

Eoin Reddan lies injured 9/3/2013

A leg fracture against French has ruled Reddan out for 12-16 weeks. (©INPHO/Morgan Treacy)

Out-half: Jonathan Sexton

Jonathan Sexton goes off injured 10/2/2013

Sexton strained his hamstring against England and tore a tendon in his foot before the Italy game. (©INPHO/Dan Sheridan)

Left wing: Simon Zebo

Simon Zebo after the match 10/2/2013

The Munster winger broke a bone in his foot against England. (©INPHO/Billy Stickland)

Inside centre: Gordon D’Arcy

Gordon D'Arcy up ended 10/2/2013

A stress fracture of the foot saw D’Arcy miss the final three matches. (©INPHO/Billy Stickland)

Outside centre: Keith Earls

Keith Earls leaves the field injured 16/3/2013

The versatile Earls dislocated his shoulder against Italy. (©INPHO/James Crombie)

Right wing: Tommy Bowe

Tommy Bowe tackled by Santiago Fernandez 24/11/2012

The Ulster winger hyper-extended his knee against Northampton Saints in December. (©INPHO/Dan Sheridan)

Fullback: Luke Fitzgerald

Luke Fitzgerald 9/3/2013

A replacement that could cover multiple backline positions, Fitzgerald injured his knee against Italy. (©INPHO/Morgan Treacy)

Subs: Craig Gilroy [groin], Luke Marshall [concussion], Tomás O’Leary [back].

Dropped: Ronan O’Gara, Tom Court, Andrew Trimble, Kevin McLaughlin.

President Higgins congratulates Ireland’s women’s rugby side

Read next:

Comments (18 Comments)

  • It can’t have all been bad luck. Need to have a good look at conditioning. We are very noticably the smallest team stature wise though.

    Reply
    • We are the smallest team, every way. We have the smallest players size wise and we have the smallest pool (along with Scotland) of players. Rugby is becoming a bigger game but we need our provinces to do well. When the provinces do well the attention is drawn towards rugby which will entice kids to the game. The more kids playing the game the more players will rise at a senior level.
      Our scrum has been poor well before the reign of Kidney, with the provinces preferring foreign players to play at Prop especially. We have to start looking at players (such as Tony Buckley, who has improved massively since joining Sale) that are playing first team rugby for their team. Our front row is a disaster and needs to be worked at.

      Reply
  • To be fair a lot of the injuries were down to pure bad luck, no amount of conditioning is going to stop you breaking bones, I do feel very sorry for these players and ultimately the performance on the park suffered, get well soon lads, we need ye for the Heineken cup, and Amblin challenge.

    Reply
  • David 18/03/13 #

    The soccer heads/Man Utd fans recently were crying about having one player sent off, and how it changed a game. Looking at that list and the games, we were probably lucky not to finish last. Roll on the Autumn and next year.

    Reply
  • Poor old Paddy Wallace, the forgotten man!

    Reply
  • Fergus McFadden at Number 8?

    More seriously, we need to look at why we picked up all these injuries. I’m not sure we can just put it down to bad luck and shrug our shoulders. We need to see if there’s anything in the training or preparation that caused it (not just at national level, but also in the provinces).

    What is particularly concerning is the number of injuries we picked up at 3/4 – Bowe, D’Arcy, Zebo, Gilroy, Marshall, Fitzgerald. With the way the game has gone I fear that these kind of players just can’t match up to the massive 3/4 who are appearing in the modern game like North, Cuthbert and Tuilagi.

    Reply
  • I wonder should the IRFU start looking seriously at GAA players over 6’4″with pace and power, and start developing them into rugby players. When you look at the size of some of the English, French and in particular the Welsh players they are seriously strong men who can run in straight lines. The bit of flair seems to be going out of rugby with these hard running backs.

    Reply
    • David 18/03/13 #

      Who said GAA players would want to leave their sport? But I agree with the rest of your comment, conditioning is an area that has been letting Ireland down for years.

      Reply
    • I dunno, those 6’4″ 17 stone guys fall hard if they’re tackled right – I’m one of them :) – and it takes them a little while to get up to speed. I think smaller more nimble players still have a real place in the game. They just have to figure out how not to get killed when they’re tackling the monsters.

      Reply
    • J Wood 18/03/13 #

      Some smaller players like Halfpenny, Shane Williams, and Wilkinson seem to have managed being smaller without becoming roadkill. I think O’Driscoll has said that Wilkinson was pound-for-pound the hardest tackler he’s faced. What do they do that keeps them in the game?

      Reply
  • Is it possible to use the women’s team for our next match?

    Reply
  • not good enough no excuses

    Reply

Add New Comment