The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 3 °C Saturday 25 May, 2013

Hurling league and championship set for revamp in 2014

The GAA has outlined the changes being considered for the All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship and the National Hurling League.

Image: ©INPHO/James Crombie

THE ROAD TO Liam McCarthy is set to take a new direction following the publication of proposals to revamp the hurling league and championship from 2014.

Among the changes to the All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship which will be considered by GAA Ard Comhairle is the introduction of a round-robin qualifying group for Leinster’s “developing counties.”

The proposal documents, approved by Coiste Bainistí last weekend and published today, also feature three options to restructure the National Hurling League including a possible return to an eight-team Division 1 or the reintroduction of league quarter-finals.

Ard Comhairle will be asked to choose one of these two options, or decide to keep the current league format, at its next meeting on 15 December.

Championship

If approved, the CCCC’s proposed changes to the All-Ireland Senior Hurling Championship would be phased in over a three-year period from 2014 to 2016, during which time the Liam McCarthy Cup would be reduced from its current 15 teams to 13.

The proposal, which the CCCC say is intended to ensure “more competitive streamlined and balanced championships for all inter-county teams”, would also allow the traditionally weaker hurling counties to win their way into the main competition via a series of promotions.

The most noticeable changes will come in Leinster where a preliminary “qualifying group” – initially featuring Laois, Antrim, Westmeath, Carlow and London — would see those developing counties compete for two spots in the provincial quarter-finals.

Kilkenny, Galway, Dublin, Wexford, Offaly will all still be guaranteed a place in the Leinster Championship proper each year, with the reigning provincial title-holders continuing to receive a bye directly into the semi-finals.

In order to reduce the competition numbers from 15 to 13 over this initial three-year period, the bottom-placed team in the qualifying group will be automatically relegated to the Christy Ring Cup in 2014 and 2015. The winner of the Christy Ring Cup will also have an opportunity to gain entry to the Liam McCarthy by beating the second-from-bottom team in a promotion/relegation play-off.

From 2016 onwards, there will be no automatic relegation to the Christy Ring Cup and instead it will be the bottom county in the qualifying group which will face the play-off.

The changes will be accompanied by a similar restructuring of the Christy Ring Cup and Nicky Rackard Cup (eight teams each) and the Lory Meagher Cup (four teams) in line with the vision outlined in the 2008 Hurling Development proposals.

In the event that Kerry qualify for the 2016 MacCarthy Cup through promotion, they would play in the Leinster qualifying group initially and if successful qualify for an additional Munster (rather than Leinster) quarter-final spot.

League

Ard Comhairle will be asked to choose between three options for the format of the 2014 National Hurling League. Option Two is to retain the “status quo” which was introduced in 2012 and will continue next season.

Option 1 would see the same basic divisional structure retained with 12 teams in Division 1 (six in 1A and six 1B), 12 in Division 2, and 10 in Division 3 (six in 3A and four in 3B).

In theory, each county in Division 1 would be able to win the league title with the top four teams in each “group” progressing to a quarter-final stage: the 1A winners playing the fourth-placed team in 1B, the 1A runners-up playing the third-placed team in 1B etc.

The fifth- and sixth-placed counties in each group would meet in a relegation play-off with the 1A losers automatically dropping down to 1B. The 1B losers would have a second chance to preserve their Division 1 status when they face the winner of the Division 2A final in a promotion/relegation decider.

Under Option 1, the 12 Division 1 counties would each be guaranteed a sixth game per season, regardless of league position.

The alternative up for discussion, Option 3, would see the league restructured again into three eight-team divisions (1, 2 and 3) with the remaining 10 counties split across Divisions 4A (six) and 4B (four).

Under this option, the eight teams in Division 1 would play seven regular games each with the top four counties qualifying for the semi-finals and final. The bottom team would then face the Division 2 champions in a promotion/relegation decider.

There will be no semi-finals in the lower divisions.

READ: The CCCC’s proposed changes for the All Ireland Senior Hurling Championship >

READ: The three proposed options for the 2014 Allianz Hurling League >

Read next:

Comments (12 Comments)

  • Talk about complicating a simple game..

    Reply
  • An open draw!! All in !!

    Reply
  • An open draw with no back door could be tried. Provincial championships could still be played separately. It would get novel pairings of counties who rarely play each other, and a chance of the stronger counties paired early giving a better chance to others. I’m from Cork by the way but wouldn’t mind seeing more teams get a chance.

    Reply
    • Couldn’t agree more, isn’t the resistance to such a common sense move coming from the Munster counties though because they hold the majority of hurling strongholds and value their Munster Championship. That could bd a separate league for them only or something though. The whole provisional system is completely backward and non-sensical, you only have to look at Galway winning a Leinster title. The GAA haven’t a clue how to run a championship or promote their own codes

      Reply
  • Lets get this straight 4 teams go directly to the semi finals if the win matches on the second Sunday of June or it was raining on any Sunday in July. 6 teams will enter a new competition, to qualify these teams will not have scored more than 2 goals in the year 1999. Teams wearing green jerseys will have to play with 14 players, and play there games on Monday nights unless that Monday is a bank holiday then the game will then be played on Christmas Eve.

    Reply
  • This is just tinkering around the edges of the problem. The simple fact is that the provincial system is fundamentally unhelpful and unbalanced especially in hurling and should be scrapped. However the vested interest will never allow this to happen so we’ll get this experiment and then in a few years another experiment and yet with the very odd breakthrough the same teams will feature over and over and over again the latter stage of the Hurling competition.

    If the GAA were to be really radical with the Hurling competition we would merge the League and Championship into one major competition. There would be an early round-robin system with A and B sub-divisions and then from there straight knock-out stages for both the All-Ireland (and the Christy Ring for the weaker counties). Promotion and relegation would exist between the A and B sub-divisions and the formation of the round-robin section would be done on a seeded open draw which would bring a freshness to the competition and the fixtures.

    I once came up with a full proposal based on the idea above (far too long and complicated to go into here) but because it would involve scrapping the provincial nature of the competition I’m more likely to be elected Miss World than ever seeing it accepted by the GAA.

    Reply
  • Changing the champ is futile…
    Cork,Tipp,Galway et al stop writing rubbish books, stop complaining about Kk tactics and instead train harder and man the f*£k up , it hurling !!!.

    Reply
  • Nothing more than a cosmetic rearranging of deck chairs. The real probably – particularly in hurling and in football to a lesser extent – is the lack of work being done at grassroots level. What’s being done to promote hurling in counties like Laois, Kerry or Roscommon?! Very little I would imagine, because both HDC and respective county boards don’t care enough. The hurling championship is as stale as it was in the 50s & 60s with 2 teams dominating. Football seems to be fairing a little better but not by much. Teams like Kildare, Wexford & Limerick have failed to make the breakthrough when given ample opportunity to do so.

    Reply
  • Great, so Kilkenny win again, Cork and Tip with an outside chance.. semi or final anyway, Galway there abouts too. The rest to play round robins before getting booted out by the big boys. Great change.

    Reply
  • May just give us the cups now so and save everyone else the bother. Up the cats

    Reply

Add New Comment