The Score uses cookies. By continuing to browse this site you are agreeing to our use of cookies. Click here to find out more »
Dublin: 16 °C Monday 20 May, 2013

Analysis: Trap made it easy for the best team on the planet

Ireland were up against it when facing the defending champions tonight. But the Ireland manager gave Spain a helping hand, writes Miguel Delaney.

Shay given and David Silva embrace after the final whistle.
Shay given and David Silva embrace after the final whistle.
Image: Inpho

WHEN SPAIN PLAY like that, it is, admittedly, exceptionally difficult to stop them.

But the truth is that, over the last four years, Spain haven’t been allowed play like that.

Because, for every exquisite goal the world champions scored, Giovanni Trapattoni made an error that facilitated their finesse.

Before going into that, though, let’s get one thing straight. Getting that result that was going to keep Ireland in the tournament was always going to be a very difficult job and, in reality, a freak historical occurrence.

What’s more, all of this should be placed in the context that Trapattoni has been a qualified success in his management of the Irish team. Individual criticisms do not amount to complete criticism of the coach.

But, tonight, those individual criticisms are justified.

To begin, it is worth stating that, as difficult as Spain are to play, they have not been given an easier time of it at an international tournament since they first won Euro 2008.

This is down to Trapattoni’s first mistake.

Since Spain swaggered their way to that victory in Switzerland and Austria, opposition sides realised that the only way to properly combat the defending European champions was to sit very deep, congest all available space and just try and hit them on the break. That was the true genesis of those minimalist 1-0 wins in the World Cup.

Tonight, Ireland did not congest that space. As early as the second minute, Andres Iniesta was allowed to pick out Xavi just yards from the Irish penalty spot. It’s been quite a while since Spain have been allowed to that in a game at this tournament level. And certainly so early in a game.

Secondly, there was the basic defensive sloppiness. As was said after the Croatia game, if you’re going to base your game on defensive solidity, you have — quite simply — be solid.

After the match, to be fair, Trapattoni put this down to something deeper.

“Something has changed since qualifying. I didn’t see this tension, these nerves then. But this is a clear symptom of a side who, when they go to a competition either feel so concerned they make basic errors or feel inferior.

“I will ask the lads how in earth it’s possible that, in two games, after two minutes, we’ve gifted them a goal. Then, we’ve given them another.

“Just like against Croatia, this means you throw any tactical plan out the window.”

inpho_00607992

Ireland’s John O’Shea and Sergio Ramos of Spain. Pic: INPHO/James Crombie

To be truthful, though, Trapattoni’s prior plan had already opened the door. Thanks to the ludicrous openness in midfield that allowed David Silva to be picked out, and then the defensive sloppiness that allowed Fernando Torres to simply carry the ball into the box, Spain struck.

Ireland never looked like doing similar. And that wasn’t just down to a lack of the ball. There was also the lack of a proper target man in a long-ball game. How can you expect a forward as immobile as Robbie Keane to forage in such a system.

Whatever about the manager’s previous impressive feats with this team and in his career, this was just illogical.

After that, of course, the game perfectly conformed to logic. Since 2007, this Spanish team have never failed to win a competitive game in which they’ve scored first.

As such, the following 87 minutes can be forgiven — even if Cesc Fabregas was the only Spanish player in the box for the corner that led to his goal.

Once Spain go ahead, they can use their passing to devastating effect. Not only do they unravel you but they exhaust you.

The sad fact is, though, that it was Trapattoni’s errors that at the very least set the platform for Spain’s later perfection.

Gdansk for the memories – but the party’s over now

‘We’re not here for a sing-song’, fumes Roy Keane after Irish defeat

Read next:

Comments (67 Comments)

  • I hope this is the cleansing event we need to get Ireland playing a less cynical style of football.

    Reply
  • World cup qualifying team
    1 Westwood
    2 Kelly
    3 Clark
    4 McCarthy
    5 Dunne C
    6 O’Shea
    7 Coleman
    8 Gibson
    9 Walters
    10 Long
    11 McClean

    Reply
  • Given cost us 4 out of the 7 goals so far. Why is Trap insisting on being so loyal to the players that got us to the Euros? You go to the Euros to win the matches so why not put out you best team!!!
    What I’ve learned from this tournament is Given should never have been starting in goal when we have a brilliant young upcoming Westwood that could not only have done a better job but also could have gained invaluable experience for another big comp. I do love Given but (unfortunately) his days are gone.
    Also Robbie Keane ran round that pitch screaming his head off at other players when he did no work to get the ball back, that just annoyed me even more, he should never have started either.
    And if you’re wondering was Duff on the field then I can tell you he was, you just didn’t notice because he did nothing!! If each of our players gave half as much heart as Andrews gave we would have done ourselves proud. Andrews man of the match for me!

    Reply
    • Keith Andrews is not technically gifted but he was by far the best player in both games.In my opinion he should be captain and lead the team out against Italy.Robbie Keane got found out at Liverpool.He should f*uck off back to LA.

      Reply
  • Trappatoni worked miracles for us to qualify, we were exposed at the highest level, we just haven’t got the players to play at that level.

    Reply
  • plato 15/06/12 #

    I agree with many of you.. But if Trap ” resigns” .. Who should take his place? We have a mediocre team at best.. You can’t make a silk purse from a sows ear.. So what we should be thinking is.. How can we fix it?

    Reply
  • I think our performance in the euros will help us start a basic statute of what it takes to compete at the top level in the coming years :)

    Reply
  • iBob101 15/06/12 #

    Against Croatia we lost possession time and time again in the air. Against Spain we lost possession time and time again on the ground. We’ve the worst pass completion record in the competition. People are talking about Spain’s passing as if they’re footballing Gods – but passing is the most basic footballing skill and easy when your opposition keeps 10 yards away from any Spanish player.

    Reply
  • Nail on head, Miguel. Great articles you’re writing by the way, really enjoying them. Well done.

    Reply
  • DufferO 15/06/12 #

    I think we’ll always have an inferior team to Spain, but to lose by 4 goals..There is no way we are that bad. This result reconfirms the whole logic of the wrong players being picked for the squad. Players playing premiership football week in week out like Hoolahan, Steven Reid and Pilkington being left out for guys who don’t have a contract with any club. If Paul Green isn’t good enough to be kept on at Derby, he isn’t good enough to play international football.

    We didn’t have the players on the pitch to play the type of football Trap wanted to play last night. He bottled it picking Keane and Cox, two guys who won’t chase players down and help out the defense. Long and Walters should have started and we would have had some type of outlet to give the ball to.

    I’m hoping that he changes the team going in to the game against Italy however I get the feeling he will keep it the same, we’ll get bashed and then he will blame the players for the result again to save face. Wrong players, wrong tactics.

    Reply
  • /// 15/06/12 #

    i think we need to accept we were not good enough on the other hand we have to be realistic we dont and may never have a football team of the standards of Spain at the minute but with good management and more effort in the future we might experience more tournaments like this one to enjoy :)

    Reply
  • This would be an interesting poll and a great time to ask it before more naive optimism takes over.

    What would be better?
    1. A higher chance of qualifying to WC 2014 with traps system, but with yawn inducing football and a danger of repeat performances like what happened this week?

    Or
    2. A more risky attacking system, more enjoyable and fun to watch,but an unknown so possibly far less chance of qualifying given the players at our disposal?

    A bit vague but what do you think? I can’t decide.

    Reply
    • Definitely the latter, we should be aspiring to play more adventurous football from a younger age and with the appointment of Wim Koevermans to the youth set up we are taking the first step towards that. The structure of football is all wrong in this country, pitches get too big too young for players which means they don’t get enough time on the ball during games. Playing 11 v 11 on huge pitches with full sized nets at 12 years old is not allowing young players to develop their skills and we end up with the types of players who can’t play close “ticky tacky” football (to rob a Brian Kerr phrase). No opportunity to play in triangles or develop close control. A complete overhaul is needed.

      Reply
    • Agree with Ross, but surprised at the lack of interest in his comment. There’s a long term problem with player development in Ireland, starting from the football ‘cradle’, and Ross suggests a few simple measures to begin to deal with it. Yet the sideline commentators are being just as blinkered as Trap in focusing only on short term considerations such as the standard of the existing pool or on varying Trap’s broken system.

      That does not mean the manager should not have varied the approach, not just last night but much sooner. When a strategy is both boring and ineffective, what kind of manager persists in sending his team out to play it?

      Reply
  • Ireland is the best country in the world. We deserve to win every game that’s ever happened

    Reply
  • With another manager we could have had a team of Given, Coleman, Dunne, O’Shea(or St.Ledger), Clarke, McGeady, Hoolanhan, Gibson, McClean, Walters and Long with players like Keane, Duff, Whealan, Doyle and Pilkington on the bench.

    To say we can’t at least compete at this level is a fallacy

    Reply
  • Jebus guys(I’m not Irish), you have NOTHING to be ashamed off.

    You played against a team that was superior in every way of the word. It was beautiful to look at and quite frankly it could have been 10-0 if not for some great defending from the Irish. No need to hang your head in shame and run amok. You dont have the players, they do.. Really as simple as that.

    Reply
    • That Spanish team will run amuck against most teams in this comp. Germany and Italy are only nations I believe can limit them. Remember Germany hammered England 4-1 in World Cup 2010. This is football and UK/Ire players are falling behind. Holland tried to break Spanish players legs in the final. They are breath-taking. My issue with Ireland is that trashing was waiting to happen. Using negative tactics against modest teams and scoring from set pieces will only get only get us so far. As shown the better teams will steamroll us. A change of direction is now required. New players, comfortable passing the ball. If Trap can’t believe anymore he should take his golden handshake and enjoy retirement.

      Reply
  • Did Spain play with a goalkeeper last nite? It was that bad I barely saw him?Terrible stuff.

    Reply
  • well done ireland ye have done the country proud.they will surely get an open top bus through the streets of dublin when they come home……….useless bastards

    Reply
  • peter 15/06/12 #

    Trap footballer okay when you have twelve games because you can correct your mistakes. Since the last world cup campaign Im saying he is a clown. Mick mccarthey should be installed asap. The players at his disposal were no better or worse than what was on show last night. Fortune favours the brave. Ireland is an ego trip for trap. He should be sacked straight away.

    Reply
  • Look on the positive side lads, there is a load of good young players to come into the team, the likes of McClean, McCarthy, Coleman, Ciaran Clark & dare I say it Stephen Ireland.

    Reply
  • If he got it wrong tactically suggest a different formation/team selection in the article rather than “sit very deep, congest all available space and just try and hit them on the break.” I’m all for criticisng sideline tactics if you can make a strong case for an alternative, which I don’t think you have in this article, I think we were outclassed by a long, long way on the night and given our pool of players to choose from (whether it be the 11 that started or otherwise) v’s theirs we were always going to be in trouble.

    Reply
    • So you didn’t watch Switzerland v Spain at the 2010 World Cup then… or USA against Spain in the 2009 Confed Cup… or Rubin Kazan against Barcelona i the 2009-10 Champions League? As I said in the piece, Spain are an almost impossible but the point to management is not to win games but to maximise your chances of doing so. Trap didn’t do that last night (and, again, this does not mean I think he’s done a bad job overall). I’ve covered almost every Spanish game at Euro 2008 and the 2010 World Cup. I’ve never seen a team who treasure possession so much given so much space. Spain have never had it so easy.

      Reply
    • That’s all well and good, my point was that you have no “here’s what we could have done differently” section to the article, as I said, you didn’t suggest an alternative formation or personnel changes. you point out correctly that they enjoyed a ludicrous amount of possession but you put forward no practical solution to counteract that. In my opinion (and that’s all it is) I think if you’re going to say the manager got it wrong you have to back that up with an alternative and some suggestions as to how he could have approached it.

      For what it’s worth, I’d have started with one striker and an extra body (Gibson) in midfield and marked their midfielders tightly rather than the stand-off and invite them at us tactic Trapatonni employs. Allowing the likes of Xavi, Iniesta & Alonso time on the ball is asking for trouble. Alonso on his own had more passes than the entire Irish team. Not sure it would have mattered either way, they have David Silva, we have Paul Green. Tactical switches can only get you so far when you don’t have the talent at your disposal.

      Reply
  • Baloney. Absolute baloney.

    Have you suggested a single change which could have altered the colour of this result? no. Because there isn’t one. It was inevitable we’d get hockeyed, regardless of tactics.

    Why?

    Read what Trap said. Watch the matches again. They were all starstruck and shellshocked. It’s a miracle they were even there in the first place.

    It’s a foundation for future attempts but any hope that we were ever getting out of the group was built on gossamer.

    Reply
    • You didn’t watch Switzerland v Spain at the 2010 World Cup then? As I said in the piece, Spain are an almost impossible but the point to management is not to win games but to maximise your chances of doing so. Trap didn’t do that last night (and, again, this does not mean I think he’s done a bad job overall). I’ve covered almost every Spanish game at Euro 2008 and the 2010 World Cup. I’ve never seen a team who treasure possession so much given so much space. Spain have never had it so easy.

      Reply
  • Harry Redknapp. Not afraid to bring young players through, plays an exciting brand of football, at 65 is unlikely to get another meaningful club job and will be waiting at least two years for the England job.

    Reply
    • Chris Hughton should be approached.He has great pedigree and worked with Brian Kerr as head coach not long ago,so he will be familiar with the set up.What is needed is an Irish manager who will bring in staff made up of professionals and ex Irish Internationals.Though the more pressing concern is the youth developement in the country and not constantly shipping rough diamonds off to the Premier League to master their craft.

      Reply
  • brazil, spain, italy, germany, portugal, none of these countries could beat us in rugby! thats tough!

    Reply
  • I really think trap needs to go after the next game, seriously he is not going to blood new players even in the next qualifying campaign who to replace him with? Harry Rednapp of course he might go for it England overlooked him and he would have a point to prove and he gets the best out of players

    Reply
  • bob 15/06/12 #

    well lamp,if anchorman is your only kudos I value your criticism as a complement.

    Reply
  • bob 15/06/12 #

    I promised my bro I would lick the dogs arse if we won! no boobs here,and won a few quid on 4-0 score.I stopped following soccer 15 years ago and for all the “hype” talk,ya need to be honest with yourselves! were shit.30k people spending money outside Ireland when we need it.sad!

    Reply
  • Spain are riding high on soccer right now, we’d thrash them at rugby. Our team, with its limitations have done us proud. And we’ve the best fans in the world.

    Reply
    • Have to agree with you about the fans but the team didn’t do us proud. Of course it’s always going to be a major task to play well against the Spainsh. All I wanted to see was every player going into each tackle with their heart on the line, go in hard and show the Spanish that even 2-3 goals down that you’re not giving up without a fight.

      Reply
    • we are embarressing. Trap is e,barressing. my spelling is embarresing

      Reply
  • GTFO Trap.

    Reply
  • Look let’s stuck to the GAA and the rugby , we seem to be better at those.

    Reply
  • Andrews did play his heart out. He’s a grafter for sure but without some creativity from someone else in midfield his efforts a fruitless. McGeady, Duff, Whealan, are worse than second rate, Keane should consider linking up with Jedward he looks about as in tune with the rest of the team as they do with each other. He should go back to LA where all the rest of the importers hang out. Trapp has lost all sense of reality. Big Jack knew our capabilities and played accordingly……Put them under pressure, worked really well. The only problem we gave The Spainish midfield last nite was making up their mind nwhich one of their unmarked team mates to pass to

    Reply
  • I am not sure why so many voices blaming Trap. No coach or other substitution could make this game different. It needs couple years to change approach and rebuild the team. Don’t get me wrong, but Irish team averages of player 30 years old and most from middle or end of the table of the premiership league. Also this is just my opinion but players from premiership can’t play international tournaments. They are maybe good for the league but that’s it. You will see England not wishing them bad, but they will be quickly out too I think. Look at Germany no big superstars there but so good team for tournaments, amazingly well work together. So no point begrudging now Ireland did what they could now and its perhaps to look into building new team, also not that Trapattoni did a bad job but you probably need now some fresh gust of wind if you know what I mean.

    Reply
  • Sorry but in my View red thumps out not trap has took us as far as he could he could if got a lot more out of them players and that’s a fact he has to go Ireland don’t have the young players coming threw to play defensive scared to play football we having attacking exiting players coming threw for 2014 And I want to see us play football that Lets the players express themselves no more Paul greens

    Reply
  • Brutal stuff!

    Reply
  • Lads played like……gay chicks……..honestly! Ireland should have been booted long ago form the championship in poland.

    Reply
  • That should have read impostersn

    Reply

Add New Comment